MercatorNet: Aboriginal people – how to misunderstand their science MercatorNet: A special year for the family - but who knew? MercatorNet: A man in love with truth and freedom MercatorNet: Earth Day eco-villains: our top 10 MercatorNet: Charlie Chaplin: born in rags, destroyed by riches MercatorNet: In a world of family change, how are children faring? MercatorNet: Could we choose to dialogue? MercatorNet: Disparate bedfellows: same-sex marriage and human rights MercatorNet: Philippines population control law gets judicial green light MercatorNet: Do you want CNN or ESPN with that burger? MercatorNet: 3 reasons not to trust the new climate report MercatorNet: Is “conscious uncoupling” really such a loopy idea? MercatorNet: Losing our virtue MercatorNet: A deal with the devil MercatorNet: “Is this the upshot of your experiment?” MercatorNet: Protecting the first “little platoon” MercatorNet: US defence policy in the wake of the Ukrainian affair MercatorNet: Why schools deny that bullying causes suicide MercatorNet: Stem cell debacle déjà vu MercatorNet: Is it OK to be a bigot? MercatorNet: Single sex schooling and gender theory MercatorNet: Does equality breed violence against women? MercatorNet: Want to comment? Use your real name, please MercatorNet: No, Costanza Miriano is not crazy MercatorNet: Russia and the US negotiate the future of Ukraine MercatorNet: The unspeakable link between family stability and prosperity MercatorNet: Dumbing down: the new SAT MercatorNet: The first harm is the biggest harm MercatorNet: If a company can be African American, can’t it be religious? MercatorNet: Marry and submit to him. What? MercatorNet: The modern hospital and its waste products 70 years under Communism have damaged generations of Russian families. MercatorNet: Scholarly “consensus” isn’t always valid MercatorNet: American strategy after Ukraine MercatorNet: Stumbling forward into the past MercatorNet: Entrenching a ‘duty to do wrong’ in medicine MercatorNet: Downton Abbey and abortion rights MercatorNet: How the Bible has shaped the West MercatorNet: Quebec gears up for a momentous election MercatorNet: For another view of World War I, look to Lord of the Rings MercatorNet: It’s Down Syndrome Day, but for how long? MercatorNet: Stage six: joy MercatorNet: Why did Russia do it? MercatorNet: A baby with a secret - of happiness MercatorNet: Men@home: Are they up to the job? MercatorNet: How we treat the vulnerable is a moral test beyond politics MercatorNet: Trampling on youthful hopes, Russia radicalizes Ukraine MercatorNet: Social science is no bogeyman MercatorNet: With Syria at war, Lebanon is bursting MercatorNet: Do citizens have the right to control their data on the web? MercatorNet: Democracy is broke. Here’s how to fix it MercatorNet: Is it right that they come? MercatorNet: “Above all liberties” MercatorNet: Radio Shack: thanks for all the memories MercatorNet: Fukushima: a man-made disaster MercatorNet: Compassionate or confusing? The Dalai Lama on same-sex marriage MercatorNet: Conversations with Islamists MercatorNet: Should the West trade Crimea for the Ukraine? MercatorNet: Annexation ‘calls into question’ the foundation of modern statehood MercatorNet: What a progressive used to be MercatorNet: College athletics and the common good MercatorNet: Equal but different: what the UN and feminism still don’t get MercatorNet: Expendable mothers MercatorNet: The marriage gap: where poor Canadians are missing out MercatorNet: You can’t see the doctor: he’s checking boxes right now MercatorNet: Barcoding embryos MercatorNet: Why Christian ideals are the foundation of a secular society MercatorNet: Taking the “mother” out of Mother Earth News MercatorNet: Why so much anarchy? MercatorNet: Ukraine’s Maidan: Return of the “Gas Princess” MercatorNet: Modern marriage: a modelling course MercatorNet: The fatal dogma which keeps the bullying epidemic afloat MercatorNet: Does having a conscience make a doctor unprofessional? Democracy in times of crisis: strong leadership vs muddling through MercatorNet: Ukraine’s revolution is over. Now what? MercatorNet: Facebook offers 56 new ways of being You MercatorNet: Things you can learn from the zombie apocalypse MercatorNet: Dialogue and disagreement MercatorNet: Is the Arab Muslim world committing “societal suicide”? MercatorNet: Is digital learning the end of education? MercatorNet: The silent war on religious liberty MercatorNet: Thinking straight about the environment Can Disney cartoons make your child nicer? A new study suggests they can. MercatorNet: The American public’s indifference to foreign affairs How to improve human rights in North Korea: foster changes already taking place Swedish nurse takes a stand on conscience rights: why can't a nurse refuse to assist at abortions? MercatorNet: Killing Americans abroad: has Obama’s policy changed? MercatorNet: Quebec should beware of euthanasia MercatorNet: Is “sex worker” a legitimate phrase? Being and Being Bought: A new feminist book sees both prostitution and surrogacy as anti-woman. MercatorNet: Facebook’s ‘look back’ is marketing in mufti A recent ruling in Virginia on same-sex marriage ignores the fundamentals of human sexuality. MercatorNet: Shouldn’t same-sex oriented teens be given a chance to change? MercatorNet: The UN’s zero-compliance with zero tolerance of abuse MercatorNet: Is a dialogue with Islam possible? Implications of the jihadist movement MercatorNet: “If you like your morality, you can keep your morality” MercatorNet: Groundhog Day turns 21 MercatorNet: Swimming against the click-stream MercatorNet: Through the underworld to transcendence
We post stuff like this every day on Facebook. Like us. You won't regret it.
Don't show this to me again

Aboriginal people – how to misunderstand their science

Only now are we starting to understand Aboriginal intellectual and scientific achievements.
Ray Norris | 24 April 2014

Just one generation ago Australian schoolkids were taught that Aboriginal people couldn’t count beyond five, wandered the desert scavenging for food, had no civilisation, couldn’t navigate and peacefully acquiesced when Western Civilisation rescued them in 1788.

How did we get it so wrong?

Australian historian Bill Gammage and others have shown that for many years land was carefully managed by Aboriginal people to maximise productivity. This resulted in fantastically fertile soils, now exploited and almost destroyed by intensive agriculture.

In some cases, Aboriginal people had sophisticated number systems, knew bush medicine, and navigated using stars and oral maps to support flourishing trade routes across the country.

They mounted fierce resistance to the British invaders, and sometimes won significant military victories such as the raids by Aboriginal warrior Pemulwuy.

Only now are we starting to understand Aboriginal intellectual and scientific achievements.

galileoThe Yolngu people, in north eastern Arnhem Land in the Northern Territory, long recognised how the tides are linked to the phases of the moon.

Back in the early 17th century, Italian scientist Galileo Galilei was still proclaiming, incorrectly, that the moon had nothing to do with tides.

Some Aboriginal people had figured out how eclipses work, and knew how the planets moved differently from the stars. They used this knowledge to regulate the cycles of travel from one place to another, maximising the availability of seasonal foods.

Why are we only finding this out now?

We owe much of our knowledge about pre-European contact Aboriginal culture to the great anthropologists of the 20th century. Their massive tomes tell us much about Aboriginal art, songs and spirituality, but are strangely silent about intellectual achievements.

They say very little about Aboriginal understanding of how the world works, or how they navigated. In anthropologist Adolphus Elkin’s 1938 book The Australian Aborigines: How to Understand Them he appears to have heard at least one songline (an oral map) without noting its significance.

[…] its cycle of the hero’s experiences as he journeyed from the north coast south and then back again north […] now in that country, then in another place, and so on, ever coming nearer until at last it was just where we were making the recording.

How could these giants of anthropology not recognise the significance of what they had been told?

The answer dawned on me when I gave a talk on Aboriginal navigation at the National Library of Australia, and posed this same question to the audience.

Afterwards, one of Elkin’s PhD students told me that Elkin worked within fixed ideas about what constituted Aboriginal culture. I realised she was describing what the American philosopher Thomas Kuhn referred to when he coined the term “paradigm”.

The paradigm problem

According to Kuhn, all of us (even scientists and anthropologists) are fallible. We grow up with a paradigm (such as “Aboriginal culture is primitive”) which we accept as true. Anything that doesn’t fit into that paradigm is dismissed as irrelevant or aberrant.

Only 200 years ago, people discussed whether Aboriginal people were “sub-human”. Ideas change slowly, and the underlying message lingers on, long after it has been falsified.

As late as 1923 Aboriginal Australians were described as “a very primitive race of people”.

Not so primitive

The prevailing paradigm in Elkin’s time was that Aboriginal culture was primitive, and Aboriginal people couldn’t possibly say anything useful about how to manage the land, or how to navigate.

So an anthropologist might study the Aboriginal people as objects, just as a biologist might study insects under a microscope, but would learn nothing from Aboriginal people themselves.

Even now, the paradigm lives on. In my experience, well-educated white Australians, trying so hard to be politically correct, often still seem to find it difficult to escape their childhood image of “primitive” Aboriginal people.

We must overcome the intellectual inertia that keeps us in that old paradigm, stopping us from recognising the enormous contribution that Aboriginal culture can make to our understanding of the world, and to our attempts to manage it.

As Thomas Kuhn said:

[…] when paradigms change, the world itself changes with them.

Still to learn

In recent years, it has become clear that traditional Aboriginal people knew a great deal about the sky, knew the cycles of movements of the stars and the complex motions of the sun, moon and planets.

There is even found a sort of “Aboriginal Stonehenge”, that points to the sunset on midsummers day and midwinters day. And I suspect that this is only the tip of the iceberg of Aboriginal astronomy.

So in the debate about whether our schools should include Aboriginal perspectives in their lessons, I argue that kids studying science today could also learn much from the way that pre-contact Aboriginal people used observation to build a picture of the world around them.

This “ethno-science” is similar to modern science in many ways, but is couched in appropriate cultural terms, without expensive telescopes and particle accelerators.

So if you want to learn about the essence of how science works, how people learn to solve practical problems, the answer may be clearer in an Aboriginal community than in a high-tech laboratory.

The Conversation

Ray Norris is Chief Research Scientist at CSIRO Astronomy & Space Science, and Adjunct Prof, Dept of Indigenous Studies (Warawara) Macquarie University at CSIRO.  He does not work for, consult to, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organisation that would benefit from this article, and has no relevant affiliations.

This article was originally published on The Conversation. Read the original article.

Copyright © Ray Norris . Published by You may download and print extracts from this article for your own personal and non-commercial use only. Contact us if you wish to discuss republication.

Follow MercatorNet
Sections and Blogs
Family Edge
Sheila Reports
Reading Matters
Demography Is Destiny
Conniptions (the editorial)
our ideals
our People
Mercator who?
partner sites
audited accounts
New Media Foundation
Suite 212
75 Archer Street
Chatswood NSW 2067
+61 2 9007 1187

© New Media Foundation 2014 | powered by Encyclomedia | designed by Elleston