MercatorNet: On July 23, 1944, Soviet troops found 800,000 pairs of shoes MercatorNet: Of astrophysics and atheism MercatorNet: Can Putin survive? When will the rivers of hatred run dry in Gaza and Israel? MercatorNet: The muddled iconography of women bishops MercatorNet: The desperate dream of the Islamic Caliphate MercatorNet: Reflections on an unforgiving day MercatorNet: Five steps Malaysia Airlines must take after its second disaster in four months MercatorNet: Why we all deserve free, yummy dark chocolate Mothers in shackles: It’s not only in Sudanese prisons that women give birth chained. MercatorNet: Celebrity swimmer Ian Thorpe comes out MercatorNet: All wired up: the contraceptive chip MercatorNet: Will the unmasking of abusers be a catalyst for change? MercatorNet: Gaza situation report Parenting as a political activity: Society needs virtuous people more than it needs laws. MercatorNet: The global niceness challenge announces a winner MercatorNet: Health economics 101: contraceptives pay for themselves, usually, babies don’t MercatorNet: Stopping the panic over Britain’s paedophiles MercatorNet: To the shores of Tripoli MercatorNet: Should I destroy my Rolf Harris CD? MercatorNet: The robot says you flunked MercatorNet: What the Supreme Court did (and didn’t do) to religious freedom last week MercatorNet: The global race to reinvent the state MercatorNet: Does sex have a purpose? MercatorNet: Why Hobby Lobby is not about women’s health MercatorNet: On its 237th birthday, some of America’s problems haven’t changed MercatorNet: The homegrown jihadist MercatorNet: Mother bodies, father bodies MercatorNet: KLM angered millions of Mexicans to make a joke about the World Cup MercatorNet: This is Iraq’s darkest hour Leading our children away from celebrity culture MercatorNet: The Sunni Ramadan offensive and the lessons of Tet MercatorNet: Balancing Ramadan against World Cup glory MercatorNet: Dialoguing with Islam MercatorNet: Finding a role for the foodie MercatorNet: Marriage, marketing, and intimidation MercatorNet: Don’t expect stable families without a living wage MercatorNet: This week’s Citadel of Political Correctness Award goes to MercatorNet: In Europe’s schools, national values infringe religious freedom MercatorNet: Unpacking the labels in the abortion debate MercatorNet: Why taekwondo won’t save girls from date rape MercatorNet: The US has unfinished business in Ukraine and Iraq MercatorNet: Meriam is free, but countless Christian women are not MercatorNet: Is dementia really Public Enemy #1? MercatorNet: Making gay okay - and criticising it taboo MercatorNet: The bitter price of divorce MercatorNet: Brown v. Board of Education turns sixty MercatorNet: An agenda for the new King of Spain MercatorNet: Will Joe Biden stop the tide of child “refugees”? MercatorNet: Shyness isn’t nice, but shyness shouldn’t stop you The intrigue lying behind Iraq's jihadist uprising MercatorNet: Hillary Clinton on gay marriage: did she evolve, or just wait? MercatorNet: The transgender movement is not the new civil rights frontier MercatorNet: Is this the most miserable place on earth? MercatorNet: The failure of Western secular values in Iraq MercatorNet: Democracy and morality: ancient and modern MercatorNet: How has Iraq lost a third of its territory to ISIS in three days? MercatorNet: Why is Richard Dawkins scaring kids out of reading fairy tales? MercatorNet: The tactics of the “beautiful game” MercatorNet: Physician, heal thyself: preventing sexual violence in war zones MercatorNet: What crisis comes after the Ukraine crisis? MercatorNet: A country priest, a Norwegian heroine, an American lady: bookmarks MercatorNet: Shoots of hope for Christians in Syria’s civil war MercatorNet: “The Switch From Hell” MercatorNet: Why are men more in favour of abortion? MercatorNet: The Fault in Our Stars MercatorNet: What is the real story behind Ireland’s mass grave? MercatorNet: “Tiananmen Square is being cleansed with blood” MercatorNet: In the beginning: why all forms of marriage in the Bible are not equal MercatorNet: New data shows drones killed hundreds of Pakistani civilians MercatorNet: What if software could suffer? MercatorNet: Those dendrites made me do it: free will and morality MercatorNet: Eurosceptics and family values MercatorNet: Is this democracy? 28 EU commissioners veto 2 million strong petition MercatorNet: Gender beyond the binary: implications for marriage MercatorNet: Motherhood at 40: how women came to believe a modern myth The Triple Package: Tiger Mom has another go at explaining what makes for success. MercatorNet: Romania’s delicate balance MercatorNet: Explainer: do 97% of scientists fear global warming? MercatorNet: 10 life lessons from Navy Seal in charge of bin Laden raid MercatorNet: Looking in the wrong places to explain another mass murder MercatorNet: Hopefully, literally, begs the question: the three most annoying misuses in English MercatorNet: The fearful symmetry of family violence MercatorNet: Who is running higher education? MercatorNet: Chaos in Calgary MercatorNet: Borderlands: Hungary manoeuvres MercatorNet: Pregnant Sudanese woman could be hanged for “apostasy” MercatorNet: Are the Roman martyrs a self-serving Christian myth? MercatorNet: Conscientious objectors got short shrift in WWI Germany MercatorNet: Paid for her silence: the exploitation of Kylee Gilman MercatorNet: Non-Negotiable MercatorNet: To aim at virtue and fall short does not a hypocrite make MercatorNet: Happy International Day of Families! Oh, you didn’t know? MercatorNet: The walls close in on Canada’s abortion foes MercatorNet: Harvard’s dance with the devil MercatorNet: Surrogate motherhood creates an ethical minefield MercatorNet: Digital clones: coming to a hologram near you MercatorNet: The curse of slavery lingers in Africa MercatorNet: Drugs Down Under: the failed experiment with legal highs MercatorNet: The abortion selfie of Emily Letts
We post stuff like this every day on Facebook. Like us. You won't regret it.
Don't show this to me again

On July 23, 1944, Soviet troops found 800,000 pairs of shoes

This was the day that the world finally realised that the horror of the extermination camps was real.
Toby Thacker | 23 July 2014
comment   | print |

One of two memorials that stand to Madjanek. Toby ThackerAuthor provided

On July 23 1944, Soviet Army troops discovered the huge Nazi concentration camp of Majdanek just outside the Polish city of Lublin, virtually intact. Along with a few hundred ill and emaciated survivors, they found plentiful evidence that men, women, and children from all over Europe had been brought to this camp by the SS, and that tens of thousands had been murdered there.

As well as the physical structures which we have since come to identify as those of the concentration camp – wooden barracks, the electrified barbed wire fences, the watchtowers, gas chambers, and crematoria – the Soviets found burial pits with the remains of human bodies, and huge quantities of ash strewn over the site. They also found documents, clothing, and more than 800,000 pairs of shoes. From survivors they quickly learnt that Majdanek had been, even in the gruesome realm of Nazi oppression, a place of particular horror.


Aerial reconnaissance of Majdanek, June 1944. Majdanek Museum.   

Today the anniversary of the liberation of Majdanek passes almost unnoticed, unlike that of the liberation of Auschwitz, fully six months later in January 1945, which has been adopted in Britain as Holocaust Memorial Day. In history books, in film and on television, the discovery of the concentration camps in Germany by Allied troops in April 1945 is recognised as a pivotal moment in world history, when humankind had to re-assess its understanding of what one set of people might do to another, after which, in Adorno’s words, it would be barbaric to write poetry.

Those born since 1945 still live in the shadow of these events, conscious of the terrible images of starving prisoners in striped uniforms, of bodies bulldozed into pits, and of the hardened faces of men and women who had presided over this horror. But why has Majdanek been forgotten?

Structures of cruelty. Toby Thacker, Author provided

Immediately after the Red Army occupied Majdanek, Soviet, Polish, and Western journalists were taken to the camp. Photographs were taken, newsreel film was shot, and a commission of enquiry was established. Reports were published in the West, but they were typically brief, and even confused.

The Times published a short piece from its Moscow correspondent on August 12 1944, entitled “The Horrors of Lublin”, implying that two separate camps had been discovered, “which suggest medieval conceptions of hell”. It stated that evidence of mass murder had been found, alongside “thousands of pairs of boots and shoes”. This and other reports in Western media highlighted the discovery of gas chambers, something which had been previously rumoured, but not confirmed. There were clearly individual readers who recognised the significance of this moment, but as the war continued, there was no wider impact.

The usual explanation for this is that there was suspicion in the West about how far the Soviets could be trusted, but this is only part of the answer. The suggestion that hundreds of thousands, even millions of people had been murdered in one camp was, at that point, almost incomprehensible. There was in fact similar incredulity when, in January 1945, similar claims were made about Auschwitz.

Where Majdanek got its victims. United States Holocaust Memorial Museum, CC BY-NC

Only in April 1945, when dozens more camps and sites of atrocity in Germany were uncovered, and when film of these camps was shown across Europe and America was there a wider acceptance that millions had indeed been murdered. As the history of the Holocaust was gradually uncovered at the Nuremberg Trial, and in succeeding decades, Majdanek, now hidden behind the Iron Curtain, was only one part of this.

Majdanek was not forgotten in Poland. The camp was turned into a museum, and efforts were made to restore the site. The first war crimes trial was held there in the autumn of 1944, and several of the staff indicted at that process were sentenced to death. In 1968 two huge memorials designed by Wiktor Tolkin were built there. Through the Cold War, Polish schoolchildren were taken to Majdanek, and since 1989 some visitors from other countries have been there.


Falling into decay. Toby Thacker, Author provided

But Majdanek has not become part of the international “Holocaust tourism” circuit. When I visited in March 2007, there were more crows than people at the bleak and exposed site of the camp. Today, Majdanek presents a serious challenge to all who are concerned with memory and our knowledge of the past. Its largely wooden buildings and their fragile contents are rotting. In 2010 a fire destroyed thousands of pairs of shoes in one barrack which had previously offered a mute testimony to the suffering of their former wearers. Should the camp be preserved for the future? Its grim structures will need continued restoration, and in some cases outright replacement if the answer to this question is yes.

In the meantime, the wind sweeps over the vast expanse of the camp, and crows perch on the rusting barbed wire. The watchtowers, barracks, and fences are horribly visible to the people of Lublin whose windows overlook the site, and who drive past on the main road to Zamość. Now, 70 years on, we must not forget what happened there.

The ConversationToby Thacker is Senior Lecturer in Modern European History at Cardiff University. He does not work for, consult to, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organisation that would benefit from this article, and has no relevant affiliations. This article was originally published on The Conversation. Read the original article.

MORE ON THESE TOPICS | Holocaust, World War II
This article is published by Toby Thacker and under a Creative Commons licence. You may republish it or translate it free of charge with attribution for non-commercial purposes following these guidelines. If you teach at a university we ask that your department make a donation. Commercial media must contact us for permission and fees. Some articles on this site are published under different terms.

comments powered by Disqus
Follow MercatorNet
Sections and Blogs
Family Edge
Sheila Reports
Reading Matters
Demography Is Destiny
Conniptions (the editorial)
our ideals
our People
Mercator who?
partner sites
audited accounts
New Media Foundation
Suite 12A, Level 2
5 George Street
North Strathfield NSW 2137
+61 2 8005 8605
skype: mercatornet

© New Media Foundation 2014 | powered by Encyclomedia | designed by Elleston