| Print |
The mighty fall and the media cash in
Why are newspapers gasping in scandalised horror over the misdeeds of Eliot Spitzer? They wrote the script.
The world news in the New Zealand
Herald yesterday was dominated by a large photo with a bold
caption identifying the subject as “The woman who brought down a
governor”. Last week the average Herald reader knew as much
about New York Governor Eliot Spitzer as New Yorkers knew about our
antipodean newspaper: nothing, nix, nada. Now we, like the rest of world,
know that Mr Spitzer has resigned from his top-ranking position and
we also know in considerable detail why: he has joined the ranks of
American politicians who have fallen from grace through sexual
misconduct -- and been discovered.
This is a sex scandal -- right? A man
has disgraced himself by having recourse to a prostitute, which is a
crime where he comes from, and paying her and her bosses tens of
thousands of dollars in ways that were also possibly criminal. He has
betrayed and humiliated his wife and three teenage daughters. Having
presented himself as a crusader against corruption and a man of moral
rectitude he has shown himself a hypocrite and undermined, further,
public confidence in government. He has ruined his own life. So
what’s with the big picture of callgirl Ashley Dupre -- the woman
Spitzer had his most recent, incriminating encounter with -- in
bikini and provocative pose, starring on the front page of section
Titillation, that’s what; shameless
and hypocritical use by the media of the individuals in this tragedy
to increase ratings and sales. And this by the world’s premier
newspapers, whose motto seems to be, “We are all tabloids now.”
Take the New York Times. On
Day One it is all shock and dismay that a liberal hero has fallen. By
Day Two they are running a detailed reconstruction of his last
assignation with the prostitute. Day Three brings a profile of Mrs
Silda Spitzer after a frantic ring around her friends to collect the
gossip on her relationship with her husband. Ironically, there is
also an opinion piece by the estranged wife of James McGreevey, the
gay former governor of New Jersey, which ends by urging respect for
Mrs Spitzer’s privacy -- of all things. Day Four it’s a profile
of Ms Dupre herself, “star of the seamy drama that is the downfall
of Gov. Eliot Spitzer of New York”, as the Times puts it.
They should know; they are co-writing the script.
Who needs all this stuff?
The public only needs to know what
affects the public interest: the criminal charges, if any, and in due
course the court findings. Judicious commentary can be helpful in
putting such events into perspective. More than that comes of the
devil. If the media were doing their jobs well, ordinary reporting
would bring to light questionable behaviour before it escalated into
a major scandal. Wall Street Journal columnist Kimberley
Strassel says the press gave Mr Spitzer an easy ride during his
campaign against corporate “big guys” while he played the bully
himself. “The former New York attorney general never believed
normal rules applied to him,” she says, “and his view was
validated time and again by an adoring press.”
Mr Spitzer concurred with the view that
forced prostitution is modern form of slavery. Last year he signed a
law creating new criminal penalties for that and other kinds of
forced labour. At the same time he increased the penalty under New
York’s existing law against patronising a prostitute. Like him, the
press comes down on forced sex and other kinds of human trafficking
like a ton of bricks, because it is politically correct to do so. The
buying and selling of sex on a consensual basis, however, finds them
All the newspapers run ads for “escort” agencies and “adult entertainment”. The Economist a couple of years ago argued brazenly that prostitution was merely part of the market and people should be left free to trade in sex if they wanted to. And what is the greater part of mass media entertainment -- from Sex In The City to Seventeen and even Barbie magazine -- but commercial exploitation of the sensuality that brought Mr Spitzer tumbling down and daily drags society deeper into the mire?
So let’s have no more gasps of horror
and crocodile tears from the media establishment over fallen idols.
Let the papers of record and the investigative journalists clean up
their own act. Instead of filling pages with the lurid details of
personal sins and social crimes, let them get on with their real job
of subjecting everyone to fair scrutiny and reporting what will
prevent abuses of power and betrayals of faith.
Ordinary people do not want to wade
through acres of smut and gossip to get to some useful news and
uplifting entertainment. They are trying to build up their families
and societies, and if the denizens of Times Square and Fleet Street
don’t want to help them, they deserve to go out of business.
Carolyn Moynihan is Deputy Editor of MercatorNet. She writes from Auckland, New Zealand.
Want to read more articles by Carolyn Moynihan Click on the links below
This article is published by Carolyn Moynihan and MercatorNet.com under a Creative Commons licence. You may republish it or translate it free of charge with attribution for non-commercial purposes following these guidelines. If you teach at a university we ask that your department make a donation. Commercial media must contact us for permission and fees. Some articles on this site are published under different terms.