August
03
  7:29:57 AM

The Unfortunate Son

The Count de Muguet was a cruel man. Indeed, his reputation made it easy to believe that he killed his wife and her midwife after his second son died at birth.

Fifteen year old Beatrice knows personally the tyrant's vicious nature. He executed her father without investigating false accusations of theft, forcing Beatrice to leave home and live in a small sea village with Mattie, her nurse, and Mattie's brother, Pons. When Luc comes to work with Pons, none of them suspect that this handsome, refined boy could be connected to the Count in any way.

Luc welcomes the change, having spent his childhood working for his alcoholic father. The foursome enjoy a comfortable routine, until Saracens kidnap Luc and sell him to a learned Arab in Africa. Salah sees the boys' potential and trains him in the art of medicine. Luc, however, resents his new master. Will he ever return to France and his life as a fisherman?

Constance Leeds' young adult adventure has an engaging, complex plot that will appeal to early teens. Beatrice and Luc are realistic characters. Luc in particular learns to accept his situation, turn tragedy to his advantage, forgive wrongs and remain loyal. Leeds' writing style is somewhat simplistic. While the books' reading level is accessible to pre-teens, its language makes it more appropriate for older readers. In addition, her ending may be disappointing. An apparent attempt at an open-ended story gives the impression that the author was not sure how to resolve loose ends. That said, this fast moving novel should keep even reluctant readers' attention.

Jennifer Minicus is a mother and teacher currently living in Ridgewood, NJ.



 
about this blog  

Search this blog

 Subscribe to Reading Matters
rss RSS feed of posts

 Recent Posts
Improving a child’s ability (& desire) to learn
17 May 2013
A Picture is Worth a Thousand…Songs?
14 May 2013
Hope lends beauty to even the bleakest tale
10 May 2013
A Modern Epic Poem
7 May 2013
Compassionate Killing: the New Darling of Teen Lit
3 May 2013

 Recommended reading
for ages 2-7
for ages 7-10
for ages 9-12
for ages 11-14
for ages 13-16
for ages 15-18
for ages 18 +
for all ages

 Archive
May 2013 | Apr 2013 | Mar 2013 | Feb 2013 | more >>

 From MercatorNet's home page

EU shows how to do a dodgy survey
16 May 2013
The EU's largest-ever survey of hate crimes and discrimination against LGBT people claims that they labour under a terrible burden.…

How legal euthanasia changed Belgium for ever
17 May 2013
The ideology of absolute self-determination has become sacred and unquestionable.

The fallacy of a happy, productive and ageing work force
17 May 2013
Glib answers will not conjure away the hard, cold fact that workers everywhere are getting older and older.

What is parenthood?
15 May 2013
In debates about the family, some social scientists are asserting the primacy of theory over facts. Is this science?

Reason and responsibility: the Rana Plaza collapse
13 May 2013
The Rana Plaza tragedy was an outcome of a corrupt system that is rotten to the core. Who should --…


 Tags
dystopia, leadership, mercy killing, music, boys, media, lists, reading, book lists, animal rights, fantasy, girls, character, siblings, science fiction, family, adoption, art, magic, blog guide, action, prejudice, war, travel, bullying, mystery, movie, books, classics, friendship, fairy tales, adventure, heroic girls, poetry, best of, young adult, movies, humor, writing, freedom, euthanasia, feminism, cooking, historical fiction, school, animals, revolution, slavery, biography, work, hope, adolescence, education, learning, picture books, science, graphic novel, culture, nature, forgiveness, Christmas, thriller, Newbery Award, romance, heroic boys, short stories, mythology, history, racism, non-fiction,