Assisted suicide battle moves to Idaho

comment   | print |

With physician-assisted suicide legal in neighbouring Washington and Oregon, Idaho legislators have introduced a bill to ban it in their state. It would make assisting another person in a suicide (or an attempted suicide) a crime. The state attorney-general says that Idaho does not have a statute banning assisted suicide.

However, the legislation also offers protections to health care workers who follow a patient’s end-of-life directive. It also protects workers who offer medication to relieve  pain or discomfort, as long as the medication isn’t intentionally given to cause death.

The Idaho Medical Association supports the bill. Susie Pouliot, the group’s CEO, says that that Idaho physicians don’t support assisted suicide.

The head of legal affairs for Compassion & Choices, the leading euthanasia lobby in the US, Kathryn Tucker, is an Idaho resident. She claims that the bill would be “an infringement on an essential human… click here to read whole article and make comments



Hawaii legislature rejects assisted suicide

comment   | print |

assistedA Hawaii legislative panel Monday unanimously voted down a bill that would have legalised physician-assisted suicide for the terminally ill, quashing the possibility that it would become legal this year. The Senate Health Committee dropped the issue after 4.5 hours of testimony intensely opposed to the proposal. Dozens of car-accident survivors, elderly care providers and disabled Hawaii residents told state legislators they shouldn’t permit terminally ill, competent adults to receive medication to end their lives.

Kevin Inouye gave testimony from his wheelchair about how he contemplated suicide for five years following a car wreck, saying he would have lied to doctors to make it happen if it had been legal to do so. "All I thought about was killing myself. I had no hope," he said, who wore a yellow sticker saying, "No doctor prescribed death." "As soon as my situation got a little bit better and I… click here to read whole article and make comments



Philip Nitschke: suicide as an art form in Tasmania

comment   | print |

Philip Nitschke and his beautiful chair 

Multi-millionaire David Walsh’s assault on the senses in his new Art Museum on the banks of the Derwent river, Hobart, would seem to be an attempt to offend almost everyone.

From rotting animal carcasses to the remains of a suicide bomber made from Belgian chocolate and an ‘excrement machine’  that mimics the human body’s waste evacuation system, there would seem to be something here to shock everyone.

Hardly surprising then that Walsh should claim that ‘understanding’ of the ‘artworks’ increases as a person’s alcohol level increases! Mmmm. Replace ‘understanding’ with ‘desensitizing’ and maybe we’re getting closer to the truth.

What drew me to comment on this bizzare museum, however, was the involvement of Dr. Philip Nitschke in the event. He had flagged some connection a month… click here to read whole article and make comments



Six countries, six defeats

comment   | print |

Last November I reported on the overwhelming defeat in the Scottish Parliament of Margo Macdonald’s End of Life Assistance (Scotland) Bill by the margin of 85 to 16.

MSPs were persuaded that any weakening of the law to allow euthanasia or assisted suicide would put vulnerable people under pressure to end their lives.

This was not an isolated incident. In January 2010, an ‘Oregon Style’ assisted suicide bill was defeated in the US state of New Hampshire by a vote of 242 to 113.

On 23 April the Canadian parliament defeated Bill C-384, a bill that would have legalized euthanasia and assisted suicide by a vote of 228 to 59.

In November a bill that would have legalized euthanasia in South Australia was defeated by a vote of 12 to 9.
click here to read whole article and make comments



Safeguards: the Precautionary Principle and the Tasmanian Premier

comment   | print |

Lara Giddings

precautionary principle n: the precept that an action should not be taken if the consequences are uncertain and potentially dangerous (World English Dictionary )

The commitment of newly appointed Tasmanian Premier Lara Giddings to supporting a euthanasia and assisted suicide agenda in that state’s parliament would seem to elevate the issue to a new alert level in the Apple Isle. The Labor/Green alliance forged by her predecessor, David Bartlett, with Greens leader, Nick McKim will, no doubt, be honoured in the next few months by the introduction of yet another euthanasia bill; amongst other initiatives one suspects.

This leaves me to wonder at the enduring nature (or lack of) and consideration given to the two inquiries conducted by the Tasmanian Parliament on euthanasia and assisted suicide in the last decade or so. In 1998 the Community Development Committee’s… click here to read whole article and make comments



German doctors set to support assisted suicide

comment   | print |


The professional association for German doctors may soon relax its disapproval of physician assisted suicide. President of the Bundesärztekammer (BAK, or National Medical Association), Jörg-Diettrich Hoppe, says that new guidelines are being finalised and will be published in the first half of the year.

Some doctors oppose change, but the tendency is clear, says Dr Hoppe. Current guidelines state that if a doctor helps someone commit suicide, he is acting unethically, and therefore unprofessionally. This will be replaced by the notion that such assistance does not belong in the medical repertoire.

Since assisted suicide is legal in Germany, this means that it will be up to each doctor to decide whether he or she will participate.

Support for physician assisted suicide seems to be growing. In June last year Germany’s highest court ruled that it was not a criminal offense to cut off life-sustaining treatment of… click here to read whole article and make comments



French Senate rejects euthanasia

comment   | print |

Francois Fillon 

After a passionate debate the French Senate has scuppered a bill allowing physician-assisted suicide. The margin was convincing – 170 to 142.

The opposition of the prime minister, François Fillon, seems to have been an important element in the result. In an article in Le Monde in late January, Mr Fillon warned against haste in a thoughtful speech (poorly translated in great haste by the editor):

“This scheme does not offer the necessary guarantees. The proliferation of definitions of the end of life and procedures introduces ambiguities and sources of legal uncertainty. The implementation of the act of euthanasia is itself surrounded by conditions that are imprecise. The proposed legislation provides no explicit obligation to consult with or even to inform the patient's family.

“Most importantly, such a scheme seems to be very dangerous. In the proposed legislation, control of actions… click here to read whole article and make comments



Euthanasia doco wins prestigious award

comment   | print |


“How to Die in Oregon,” an film about the impact of Oregon’s 1994 Death With Dignity Act, has won the prestigious Grand Jury Prize in the US Documentary Competition at the 2011 Sundance Film Festival.

It opens with cancer patient Roger Sagner drinking a lethal drug surrounded by friends and family and it includes an interview with Randy Stroup, an uninsured cancer patient who was offered death with dignity by the Oregon Health Department as a low-cost end-of-life option.

The documentary focuses on 54-year-old wife and mother Cody Curtis, who is suffering from liver cancer. After an unsuccessful 9-hour operation, she decides that she does not want to linger on as a burden on her family. Although she sets the date of her death for Memorial Day (in May), she feels reasonably well and defers it until December 7.

“The film becomes a story of this extraordinary period when she’s… click here to read whole article and make comments



Tasmania’s new premier backs euthanasia

comment   | print |

Lara Giddings

The new Premier of the Australian state of Tasmania has promised to back a voluntary euthanasia bill. Lara Giddings, a 38-year-old career Labor politician, has stepped into the leadership after David Bartlett resigned to spend more time with his young family.

Ms Giddings has a difficult task ahead of her as the leader of a minority Labor government in partnership with the Greens. She can only stay in office by courting them, but she also needs to ensure that her coalition partners do not continue to steal the votes of social progressives who have voted for Labor in the past. 

On her first day in office, Ms Giddings appealed to the Greens by confirming that she would support voluntary euthanasia. A private bill which proposed by one of the two Green members of her cabinet, Nick McKim, is currently before the state parliament.

click here to read whole article and make comments



No right to assisted suicide, says European Rights Court

comment   | print |

There is no human right to assisted suicide, the European Court of Human Rights has declared, in a unanimous verdict.  

The background to this important judgement is in Switzerland. A 57-year-old Swiss national, Ernst G. Haas, felt that he could no longer live a dignified life after battling a serious bipolar affective disorder for 20 years. He twice attempted suicide, but then hit upon the idea of using sodium pentobarbital, a prescription-only drug. But no psychiatrist would prescribe it for him. He then asked the Swiss government for permission to obtain sodium pentobarbital without a prescription. He argued that Article 8 imposed on the State a “positive obligation” to create the conditions for suicide to be committed without the risk of failure and without pain.

Various Swiss courts refused. Mr Haas then asked 170 different psychiatrists whether they could examine him with a view to getting his hands… click here to read whole article and make comments


Page 16 of 19 : ‹ First  < 14 15 16 17 18 >  Last ›

Careful! is MercatorNet's blog about end-of-life issues. We respect the dignity of each person from the beginning of life to its natural end. Leave your comments at the foot of our articles. The more the better! Write to us at

rss Subscribe to Careful RSS feed

Follow MercatorNet
Sections and Blogs
Family Edge
Sheila Reports
Reading Matters
Demography Is Destiny
Conniptions (the editorial)
our ideals
our People
Mercator who?
partner sites
audited accounts
New Media Foundation
Suite 12A, Level 2
5 George Street
North Strathfield NSW 2137
+61 2 8005 8605
skype: mercatornet
© New Media Foundation 2014 | powered by Encyclomedia | designed by Elleston