7:42:49 AM

An “odious, zombie-like Malthusian” organisation has a plan to save the world


Not even the journalists reporting from the Copenhagen summit on climate change understand all the complex economic and technological strategies for reducing the world's carbon footprint and averting catastrophic global warming -- let alone the rest of us. There's cap and trade, emissions trading schemes, carbon taxes, discount rates and a phonebook of acronyms. But there is one equation which could be a very easy sell to save the world: fewer people = fewer carbon footprints.

This has been the theme of the United Nations Population Fund and other Malthusian groups for years. But it has been repackaged as a carbon offset program by a British group, the Optimum Population Trust, which British sociologist Frank Furedi describes in the on-line magazine Spiked as 'an odious... zombie-like Malthusian organisation devoted to the cause of human depletion”. Forget planting trees, wind power or solar energy. The cheapest way to reduce human-generated carbon output is contraception.

To help people invest in contraception and family planning, it has devised what it calls “PopOffsets” -- “the first project in the world that, simply and transparently, enables individuals and organizations to offset their carbon footprint by funding the unmet need for family planning”. At the PopOffsets website you can calculate how much it will cost to offset your carbon footprint for a year if you invest it in family planning. The OPT has calculated that every US$7 spent on world family planning will prevent one birth in a developing country. As it repeats over and over again, “a ‘non-person’ cannot produce CO2 (nor can their non-descendants”. It estimates that “every £4 spent on family planning saves one tonne of CO2.  A similar reduction would require an £8 investment in tree planting, £15 in wind power, £31 in solar energy and £56 in hybrid vehicle technology.”

Preventing births of poor people (most of them in Africa) is basically the OPT's plan for the planet -- rather than helping them grow richer.. As it puts it, “one less birth into poverty is not only one less person to suffer poverty and the expected severe impacts of climate change, but also one less to produce more greenhouse gases in (hopefully) escaping poverty”.

Incredibly, this proposal is being backed by some glittering names. David Attenborough, the famous documentary maker, is a patron of the OPT, and a strong supporter of limiting population. Paul Ehrlich, an ardent campaigner for  population control, Jane Goodall, the chimpanzee expert, and James Lovelock, the originator of the Gaia hypothesis are amongst the other patrons.

Professor Furedi -- a secular humanist with a Marxist background -- argues that this Malthusian initiative discounts human ingenuity and creativity and shows a distrust for humanity itself:

What is truly disturbing about this, from a humanist perspective, is not simply that there is a silent crusade against the unique quality of human life, but that there is an almost complete absence of anger about it, a lack of any critical reaction against it. In modern times, there have always been small coteries of Malthusians, eugenic fantasists and bitter misanthropists who were estranged from children and who regarded babies as an imposition on their existences. Thankfully, these people tended to be consigned to the margins of society. Not any more.

Why is it that, today, the provision of contraception can be promoted as a sensible way of reducing carbon emissions? How do we account for the silence of religious movements whose theology still upholds the unique status of human life? And why are prominent so-called humanists so uninterested in countering this lethal Malthusian challenge to some of the most important ideals that emerged during the Renaissance and later developed through the Enlightenment?
However repugnant and racist this idea seems, its simplicity could be attractive to many people.

to make a comment, click here

about this blog | Bookmark and Share

Search this blog

 Subscribe to Demography is Destiny
rss RSS feed of posts

 Recent Posts
Iran leads Muslim countries in fertility decline
20 Apr 2014
Russia: Growing and More Assertive
14 Apr 2014
Japan’s Shrinking Role in the World
8 Apr 2014
Why you shouldn’t take alarmist population predictions seriously
6 Apr 2014
Is Single Occupancy Vandalising the Environment?
4 Apr 2014

 MercatorNet blogs
Style and culture: Tiger Print
Family social policy: Family Edge
US political scene: Sheila Liaugminas
News about bioethics: BioEdge
From the editors: Conniptions

Apr 2014 | Mar 2014 | Feb 2014 | Jan 2014 | more >>

 From MercatorNet's home page

Is “conscious uncoupling” really such a loopy idea?
15 Apr 2014
Gwyneth Paltrow was ridiculed when she explained her divorce, but there's a nugget of truth in her words.

A deal with the devil
11 Apr 2014
Why did American officials refuse to prosecute Japanese doctors who had committed horrendous crimes in World War II?

“Is this the upshot of your experiment?”
10 Apr 2014
A Nathaniel Hawthorne tale of scientific obsession sheds light on today's designer children.

Protecting the first “little platoon”
10 Apr 2014
Society needs family values - but not the faith they are based on? Where a liberal proposal falls down.

US defence policy in the wake of the Ukrainian affair
10 Apr 2014
Rethinking American strategy in the framework of conventional war against enemies fighting on their own terrain.

environmentalism, Falkland Islands, populaiton growth, malthus, military, old age, disability, Australia, Jonathan Sacks, fertility rate, Britain, Elderly, jobs and economy, North Korea, Baby boomers, brain, anti-humanism, polio, Denmark, integration, over-population, Rugby World Cup, Portugal, Canna, Rome, Baby Boomers, Sex Imbalance, contraceptives, death, Ban Ki-moon, Happiness, sex selective abortion, Norman Borlaug, grandchildren, Congress, young adults, forced sterilisation, declining fertility, Gender Imbalance, healthcare, Africa, science, Hong Kong, spending, Latin America, skills shortage, Jonathan Last, population ageing, Turkey, Ted Turner, environment, Food wastage, urbanisation, Demographic Summit, Liechtenstein, China, overpopulation fiction, Carbon Credits, Population Association of America, increasing birth rates, Telegraph, aging, Ma Jian, internal migration, world hunger, Germany, centenarians, Technology, Crimea, pi, Bangladesh, internet, Sweden, West Virginia, sex selective abortions, Brazil, Educated women, family size, Marriage, economy, Roma, birthrate, gendercide, travel, global hunger, Chinese New Year, Medicaid, workforce shortage, Oxfam, one-child policy, Uzbekistan, population increase, euthanasia, humanism, society, demographic dividend, Obama administration , relationships, elections, Pope Francis,
Follow MercatorNet
Sections and Blogs
Family Edge
Sheila Reports
Reading Matters
Demography Is Destiny
Conniptions (the editorial)
our ideals
our People
Mercator who?
partner sites
audited accounts
New Media Foundation
Suite 212
75 Archer Street
Chatswood NSW 2067
+61 2 9007 1187

© New Media Foundation 2014 | powered by Encyclomedia | designed by Elleston