November
12th
  7:44:34 AM

A view from Pakistan

Today I thought that I’d share with you a piece from Pakistan - a developing country that could be in line to have a photo of its babies accompany doomsday media pieces announcing massive population increases in the world (see the blog earlier this week for an explanation of what I’m talking about).  Writing in the Pakistan Observer, Khalid Saleem discusses the implications of living in a world of seven billion people and why one can be sceptical of the ‘population control’ meme coming from certain organisations (generally in the West).  Saleem’s argument can perhaps stand as a small antidote to the Western-focussed debate on demography. 

“The world was authoritatively informed that controlling ‘population’ was the sine qua non of economic progress. In simple terms, any nation that that desired to move up the economic ladder was ‘advised’ to take steps to control the growth of its population by means fair or foul.

All this led, in due course, to the rich countries setting aside billions of dollars in ‘aid (read tied loans) to the Third World for what were termed as ‘population control projects’. All well and good! The only snag was that the whole issue was blown out of all proportion and, what is more, was used as a handy stick to chastise the developing countries with. At the same time, it served as a pretext to stop the poor of the world to cast a covetous eye on the abundant food surpluses of the First World.”

‘Population control’ measures means that those in the ‘have’ countries can assuage their consciences.  The world will be able to hold all of us because others were cutting back (in babies) rather than us having to cut back (in material consumption). 

“The economic experts of developed nations rested easy in the understanding that, with lesser mouths to feed worldwide, the haves could continue with their extravagant existence.  For years on end the blame for the world’s ills was put squarely on the poor people’s propensity to reproduce. The rich nations were outside the equation since they not only had ample to eat but lots left over to hoard or dump into the sea as they wished. The haves’ principal concern was nothing more than not having to share their bounty with the have-nots. Their whiz kids argued that if only the world’s deprived lot could be coerced into resisting the urge to add to their number, their own ‘have’ status would not risk being dented.”

As we have said before, when we talk about the world needing to have less people (or less babies) we often implicitly saying that the world should have less African/Latin American/South Asian babies as these are the areas on the worlds with the highest fertility rates.  Maybe it would be useful to find out from time to time what people in those countries think about the whole population explosion. 



to make a comment, click here


 
about this blog | Bookmark and Share

Search this blog

 Subscribe to Demography is Destiny
rss RSS feed of posts

 Recent Posts
Russia: Growing and More Assertive
14 Apr 2014
Japan’s Shrinking Role in the World
8 Apr 2014
Why you shouldn’t take alarmist population predictions seriously
6 Apr 2014
Is Single Occupancy Vandalising the Environment?
4 Apr 2014
Worldwide migration: a constant factor
1 Apr 2014

 MercatorNet blogs
Style and culture: Tiger Print
Family social policy: Family Edge
US political scene: Sheila Liaugminas
News about bioethics: BioEdge
From the editors: Conniptions

 Archive
Apr 2014 | Mar 2014 | Feb 2014 | Jan 2014 | more >>

 From MercatorNet's home page

A deal with the devil
11 Apr 2014
Why did American officials refuse to prosecute Japanese doctors who had committed horrendous crimes in World War II?

“Is this the upshot of your experiment?”
10 Apr 2014
A Nathaniel Hawthorne tale of scientific obsession sheds light on today's designer children.

Protecting the first “little platoon”
10 Apr 2014
Society needs family values - but not the faith they are based on? Where a liberal proposal falls down.

US defence policy in the wake of the Ukrainian affair
10 Apr 2014
Rethinking American strategy in the framework of conventional war against enemies fighting on their own terrain.

Why schools deny that bullying causes suicide
8 Apr 2014
They can't afford to take responsibility for their failed policies.


 Tags
internal migration, Christmas, Christianity, Elderly, Jonathan Last, Viagra, demographic dividend, France, spending, videos, Europe, debt, census, Bangladesh, Guardian, women, forced sterilisation, Egypt, government subsidies, recession, demographic winter, Adam Smith, overpopulation fiction, United States, statistics, Auckland, Bulgaria, Sir Andrew Green, Denmark, sustainable development, Old age, Rwanda, suffering, food distribution, Economics, Youth, food production, Muslim-Christian demography, child restriction policy, British Royal Family, Melinda Gates, Contraception, careers, Save the Children Fund, One Child Policy, Churchill, European Union, environmentalism, demography, culture wars, immigration, Copenhagen, IVF, immigration reform, Hispanic, family policy, Brendan O'Neill, over-population, bankruptcy, disease, New Forests Company, Romania, Birth, Belfast, military, life expectancy, food wastage, Brad Wilcox, pregnancy, Inheritance, employment, Internet use, Population reduction, global hunger, healthcare, Demographic Intelligence, EU, centenarians, Dan Brown, South Korea, rural depopulation, Western Australia, polio, labor shortages, carbon emissions, United Nations, Wall Street Journal, Technology, Wilmoth, migration, Migration, humanism, Budgeting, Deaths, ITU, World Bank, Population Research Institute, election, Human Resources, Iran,
Follow MercatorNet
Facebook
Twitter
Newsletters
Sections and Blogs
Harambee
PopCorn
Conjugality
Careful!
Family Edge
Sheila Reports
Reading Matters
Demography Is Destiny
Bioedge
Conniptions (the editorial)
Connecting
Information
our ideals
our People
Mercator who?
partner sites
audited accounts
donate
New Media Foundation
Suite 212
75 Archer Street
Chatswood NSW 2067
Australia

editor@mercatornet.com
+61 2 9007 1187

© New Media Foundation 2014 | powered by Encyclomedia | designed by Elleston