Carolyn Moynihan | Thursday, 10 July 2008

Gay rights should not trump freedom of conscience - UK tribunal

A British registrar who was harassed and discriminated against after she refused to carry out same-sex civil partnership ceremonies has won a key legal battle. An employment tribunal found that the borough council for which she worked showed no respect for Lillian Ladele’s rights “by virtue of her orthodox Christian beliefs”. The tribunal decided that gay rights should not be allowed to “trump” the rights of those with religious beliefs and said that the council’s other registrars were able to provide a “first-class” service to same-sex couples without Mrs Ladele’s involvement.

Mrs Ladele, who is now expected to return to work, wept as she told the tribunal that her bosses ordered her to perform the ceremonies or face dismissal for gross misconduct. She said: “I felt harassed and victimised. I was being picked on a daily basis.” She added: “This is a victory for religious liberty, not just for myself but for others in a similar position. Gay rights should not be used as an excuse to bully and harass people over their religious beliefs.” ~ Times (UK), July 11

See previous MercatorNet coverage: Uncivil conduct

 

Comments (2)

Mal said...

At last some good news from Britain! I believe that all these newly gained ‘rights’ should never override existing individual and social rights that have served the British well for many generations. Many of us have observed that militant advocates for the new rights have been trying to manipulate the various systems in order to ensure that their rights make others’ existing rights obsolete. Three cheers to this employment tribunal. Now we need to fight to re-assert adoptee’s rights to be placed in a well balanced home. Adopter’s rights should not take precedence here.

Australia | Friday, 11 July 2008 at 4:46 pm

David Page said...

Lillian Ladele gamed the system. No victory was achieved here. As is always the case, the precedent is the problem. I wonder what Pandora’s box will be opened when other religious groups decide that their religious law is more important than the laws of their adopted country. England should realize that the first rule of getting out of a hole is to stop digging.

United States | Sunday, 13 July 2008 at 12:53 pm

Page 1 of 1 :

New comment

Name:
Email:
Location:
URL:
0/2000
Remember my personal information
Notify me of follow-up comments?
Type the characters you see in the image below:

freeupdates

Email

frontpage rss

America’s most public pregnancy Some culture wars start this way: a small bombshell in an out-of-the-way place and before you know it, they're lobbing grenades.
Brian Lilley | 5 Sep 2008

China at the crossroads Despite its Olympian ambitions, China's government seems ineffectual at improving the lot of its poorest citizens. Constance Kong | 4 Sep 2008

The web v. the book Googling, skimming, flitting from one link to another involves reading, but not as we have known it. Carolyn Moynihan | 3 Sep 2008

The Medvedev doctrine Russian intervention in Georgia presents the United States with a massive strategic dilemma.
George Friedman | 3 Sep 2008

Does making babies make sense? Why so many people find it difficult to see humanity in a developing foetus. Richard Stith | 2 Sep 2008

Coddling kindergartners Staggered school entry? What next from the bubble-wrap department? Barbara Lilley | 1 Sep 2008

Getting better all the time Where is the evidence that the planet is getting poorer, more polluted and hungrier Louise Staley | 1 Sep 2008

Is Georgia the first cyberwar? Talk of a new era of war over the internet is just overheated rhetoric.  John Bambenek | 30 Aug 2008

A new oath for doctors: the customer is always right Conscientious objection is becoming harder and harder for doctors in the United States, Canada and Britain. Lea Singh | 29 Aug 2008

You gotta have faith Joe Biden's nomination as Barack Obama's running mate casts a shadow over the Democrats' campaign.  Brian Lilley | 27 Aug 2008

more...

rss del.icio.us technorati digg sitemap invite