August
10th
  5:20:46 PM

Kids are ‘interested’ in TV, but so are apes

I promised something more on Aric Sigman, the (American-born, as it turns out) psychologist who has made a name for himself in Britain as a fiery critic of the way television and other screen media are dominating the lives of children. So here is the next instalment.

I heard Dr Sigman address a forum of about 200 family-minded people in Auckland, New Zealand, a few days ago. He appeared on the stage looking like a 20-year-old (in fact, he is over 50) who had just done a workout at the gym, in a black t-shirt and grey jeans and almost vibrating with energy as he launched into his presentation on how “screen time” is ruining a generation.

Not that he isn’t grateful for PowerPoint (“I could kiss Bill Gates for that -- and ditto Google") which he used to good effect. And not that he doesn’t use a cellphone, a computer, or watch anything on TV. No. But what is good and useful for adults is not necessarily good for kids, especially very young ones and especially in large doses. That is the message he is trying to get across to parents and government committees and people in general.

Aric Sigman“The trend towards pushing kids to use technology early, on the basis that otherwise they will miss out later on is absolute nonsense,” he declared, in characteristic hard-nosed style.

The fact that children like computers and that they are “interested” in them might melt the heart of an educator who thinks, well, at least they are interested in something, but it cuts no ice with father-of-four Sigman. Apes can appreciate TV, Sigman pointed out; gorillas at New York zoo have their favourite programmes -- they like music, colour and movement. Just like little children.

“Just because children are interested in something doesn’t mean they ought to have it,” he stressed, to approving nods and knowing murmurs. He labours the point because politicians who control education do not seem to be able to get it, and that is because the advice they receive is dominated by people with a vested interest in technology and e-learning, he claims. “We need people who are only interested in child wellbeing.”

Sigman cited a lot of research to prove his points, among them a couple of recent studies that showed giving poorer children computers to use at home did nothing on the whole for their academic grades but did give them “computer skills”. Of course; you can learn a lot of skills using a computer, even if it is only to play games. I did a post on these studies a few weeks ago.

There is a lot more I could report about Dr Sigman’s work on technology and also the decline of parental authority, but MercatorNet will run a review of his books later on. For the moment I will just note that the biggest damage he sees being done is to children’s ability to relate to others -- their parents, siblings, friends, anyone. Kids mesmerised by screens do not learn to make eye contact; they do not acknowledge that they are passing another person. They lack empathy. And that is very bad news both for them and for society.

Here are some live interviews with Dr Sigman in Auckland.



 
about this blog | Bookmark and Share

Search this blog

 Subscribe to FamilyEdge
rss RSS feed of posts

 Recent Posts
Housewife revival is not such a bad thing
23 May 2013
Declaration of 2013 World Congress of Families
21 May 2013
World Congress of Families 2013
19 May 2013
Rise of the stay-at-home dad
15 May 2013
Record proportion of new mothers are college educated
13 May 2013

 MercatorNet blogs
Style and culture: Tiger Print
US political scene: Sheila Liaugminas
News about bioethics: BioEdge
From the editors: Conniptions

 Archive
May 2013 | Apr 2013 | Mar 2013 | more >>

 From MercatorNet's home page

The Boy Scouts cave in
24 May 2013
Under enormous pressure, they have voted to welcome openly gay scouts. What message does the change in policy send young…

A boy’s life with unisex scouts
23 May 2013
The Boy Scouts of America will vote today on whether they will admit homosexual scouts. Will they become the Unisex…

Necessary excuses
23 May 2013
“Comfort women”, carpet bombing, atom bombs, lethal drones and genocide can all be justified by appeals to necessity.

Digital multitasking: scourge or blessing?
22 May 2013
How can we teach students to focus on what they ought to be doing?

Who or what is a “child”?
22 May 2013
Canada's Parliament lacks the courage to take a stand on defining when an unborn child will be protected by the…


 Tags
friendship, sex education, abstinence, child abuse, trafficking, Facebook, violence, brain, technology, character education, mothers, religion, anger, mental health, same-sex parenting, cohabitation, internet safety, family breakdown, emerging adults, social networking, women, USA, language, parental rights, young adult, feminism, family meals, media, South Africa, self-control, pornography, dating, childcare, happiness, education of children, child behaviour, character, large families, sexual behaviour, Africa, family policy, birth control, men, children, contraception, unemployment, child obesity, books, adolescence, one-child policy, social media, recession, economics, divorce, abortion, youth, adoption, research, education, United States, homosexuality, internet, HIVAIDS, France, sleep, motherhood, work, obesity, ageing, child poverty, girls, children's health, teen pregnancy, family structure, child wellbeing, texting, gendercide, fatherhood, marriage, family economics, United Nations, same-sex marriage, child development, ageing population, daycare, parents, HomeMakers Project, commitment, names, Australia, Spain, morality, fathers, boys, media ethics, demography, Sweden, child safety, work-life balance, gender equality, prostitution, China, teenage pregnancy, UK, teenagers, video games, modesty, pregnancy, adolescents, Hollywood, television, New Zealand, celebrities, European Union, polygamy, AIDS, family relationships, homeschooling, baby boomers, fashion, family values, suicide, smacking, psychology, families, health, poverty, family, sexualisation of children, parenthood, single motherhood, child welfare, fertility, working mothers, Canada, National Marriage Project, immigration, Barack Obama, parenting, schools, gender,