David Quinn of the Iona Institute in Ireland has a different take on The Economist's story...
The cover story of The Economist last week was called ‘Asia’s lonely hearts: Why Asian women are rejecting marriage
and what that means’. The picture on the front was of a lovelorn Asian
man, rose in hand, and a woman striding purposefully away from him.
story was really about East Asian women. It told us that throughout
East Asia, in countries like Japan and South Korea, the age at which men
and women marry has risen to 29-30 in the case of women, and 31-33 in
the case of men.
It reports that a third of Japanese women in their early 30s are unmarried and “perhaps half of those always will be”.
In Taiwan, a fifth of women in their late 30s are single, and in Bangkok a fifth of women aged 40-44 are unmarried.
It says that this trend has not yet affected either China or India.
attributes the delay by East Asian women in getting married, or not
getting married at all, to two main causes. One is that more and more
are going on to third level education and that on its own will mean
The second is that they believe most of the
workload of family life is placed on their shoulders, much more of it
than in Western countries. For example, they are expected not only to
look after their children, but also aged parents, even when they are
The article gives the very strong impression
that marriage is something best avoided by women. For example, one
drawing has a successful and modern looking woman rejecting the
hand-cuffs of marriage.
The article has nothing good to say about
marriage. In fact, having read it is a wonder any East Asian women
marry, unless forced by families as in parts of South Asia, or by a
ticking biological clock in societies which still frown on
out-of-wedlock births, as is still the case in Asia.
report doesn’t consider is whether East Asian men are also becoming
averse to marriage. It seems to assume, as in the cover picture that men
want to get married and women are rejecting them.
the men themselves aren’t asking until they are in their thirties, if at
all, and perhaps many of those women (and men) who remain single aren’t
voluntarily single. Maybe they delayed marriage for too long.
the West, the average age at which men and women marry has also
increased a lot, as in East Asia. And one reason for this, again like in
East Asia, is that more and more people – men and women – are going on
to third level education.
But another reason is that the
twenties are now regarded as the time to maximise personal freedom which
means putting off the commitments and responsibilities associated with
This phenomenon of putting off adulthood is now so widespread that sociologists have given it a name; ‘emerging adulthood’.
suspect it’s true that too much is expected of Asian women compared
with men once they marry, but I also suspect that a big reason why both
sexes are putting off marriage is because, like their Western
counterparts, they are increasingly placing personal freedom above
commitment, at least when in their twenties.