Carolyn Moynihan | Friday, 20 June 2008

Women on the front line of war

Sarah BryantThe gender revolution that has girls playing football and their mothers running corporations hit a speed bump this week when a woman intelligence officer was killed, along with three other reserve members of the Special Air Service, while on a secret counter-terrorism mission in Afghanistan. The groups’ armoured vehicles were hit by a roadside bomb.

The death of Sarah Bryant, 26 and married two years ago to a fellow intelligence officer, has raised questions about Britain’s increasing use of women on the front line of war. Soldiers are now routinely selected for operations regardless of their gender. About a fifth of the 8000 British service personnel in Afghanistan are women, even though they make up just a tenth of total army numbers. Army rules forbid the deployment of women in operations where they would be expected to “close with and kill the enemy”, but such traditional definitions of front-line warfare don’t apply to conditions in Afghanistan and Iraq.

“We now have an asymmetric battlefield,” said Major Bruce Spencer. The front line could be right outside the camp gates or 50 miles away. We select people on the basis of what they can do, not on the basis of their gender. Women are part of the full panoply of the Armed Forces. The risks that they take are the same as anybody else, and they understand the risks.” A Tory MP and former soldier told the Times, “I don’t necessarily like it very much. But she signed up.” ~ The Times (UK), June 19 

Comments (1)

David J. Webb said...

Carolyn,

I don’t understand the point you are trying to make here. I am a Catholic Army officer and served in OIF in 2004-2005.

Firstly, the modern military enlists only volunteers. No one is a conscript. All enlist freely. Soldiers are not victims and should not be pitied - wars are awful and involve casualties and KIAs. Every soldier knows this and knows someone who didn’t come home. However, our wars, especially against Islamic jihadism, are just wars. So while you may be a Catholic, please don’t assume that all Catholics are anti-war or into surrender. Your pacifism is not mine. You need to read more widely and just grow up about the Islamic threat. Whether you like it or not, it is SGT Bryant and others who are defending Christian civilisation, not hippy pacifists and Barack Obama.

Secondly, the modern military could not operate without female troops. Females are vital to all sea, land and air forces, especially in combat support roles. A woman’s place is just as necessary in war, same as a man is. The army is a family and we all fight as one.

Thirdly, I followed the link and read that Sarah Bryant (RIP) was SGT Bryant.  This means that she enlisted at least 6-9 years ago and was a senior soldier in her unit. She would have had command responsibilities for junior soldiers and was a true combat leader.  Please admire her for her leadership in a forward area.

In sum, SGT Bryant died doing her duty in the finest tradition of the British Army. God rest her brave soul. She is a role model for other soldiers, male and female.

DJ Webb

United States | Wednesday, 25 June 2008 at 9:13 am

Page 1 of 1 :

New comment

Name:
Email:
Location:
URL:
0/2000
Remember my personal information
Notify me of follow-up comments?
Type the characters you see in the image below:

freeupdates

Email

frontpage rss

In the Blink of an Eye A Nigerian TV host who is not afraid of being politically incorrect.
Nwachukwu Egbunike | 21 Aug 2008

Family resemblances Two visions of English family life in classic British portraiture.
Francis Phillips | 20 Aug 2008

The real world order Like every century before it, the 21st century will be a time of conflict between nation-states, not a time to beat swords into ploughshares.  George Friedman | 19 Aug 2008

The great Saddleback debate Can we expect megachurch pastor Rick Warren to play hard ball with politicians? Mary Hinton | 16 Aug 2008

Affirming life “I am carrying this baby as long as he will let me, and will not be the killing hand.” Margaret Somerville | 15 Aug 2008

Nation of Bastards The drive for the legalisation of same sex marriage is destroying the traditional concept of marriage, says a Canadian academic.
Richard Bastien | 15 Aug 2008

In Oregon, you have lots of options Oregon finds that it's cheaper to allow patients to commit suicide.  Michael Cook | 15 Aug 2008

The roots of European unity Without the moral vision of its founding fathers the new Europe is a hollow and fragile achievement. Margriet Krijtenburg | 13 Aug 2008

The Russo-Georgian war and the balance of power The Russian invasion of its tiny neighbour is a sign that the Bear has not forgotten its imperial past. George Friedman | 13 Aug 2008

Eyes on the Beijing Olympics It’s not all the result of bullying. The West could learn something from the Chinese ethic of working together. Carolyn Moynihan | 9 Aug 2008

more...

rss del.icio.us technorati digg sitemap invite