January
21
  1:31:40 PM

No “smoking gun” in Irish TV revelations


Fr Federico LombardiA programme about clerical sexual abuse aired January 17 by Irish broadcaster RTE attempted to prove that the Vatican had a worldwide policy encouraging bishops to conceal sexual abuse by priests. Reliable reporters say that the programme, aired just ahead of a Vatican-sponsored Apostolic Visitation of the Irish church, failed to make its claim stick.

The doco, “Unspeakable Crimes”, was based on a January 1997 letter from the papal ambassador to Ireland, communicating the opinion of the Vatican’s Congregation for Clergy about a set of proposed Irish policies on priestly sexual abuse. It confirms, says John Allen of National Catholic Reporter, “that in the late 1990s the Vatican was ambivalent about requirements that bishops be required to report abuse to police and civil prosecutors.”

In it, Storero, who died in 2000, writes that the Congregation for the Clergy had concluded that a “mandatory reporting” policy, proposed by a draft 1996 set of policies considered by the Irish bishops, “gives rise to serious reservations of both a moral and a canonical nature.”

That line has fueled charges that the Vatican effectively tied the hands of bishops, preventing them from turning over abuse cases to civil authorities.

American attorney, Jeffrey Anderson (who, having run out of US clients for his lucrative line of suing the Catholic Church, has recently set up shop in Britain) claimed the letter was yet another “smoking gun” indicating a conspiracy to suppress evidence of sexual assaults by Catholic priests. But Allen, who prides himself on his objective view of the Church, says there are three reasons that claim won’t stick.

As usual, there is some background to understand, but in brief:

* The “main concern of the letter is to ensure that when a bishop takes action against an abuser, his edict should stick – suggesting a fairly tough line on abuse, rather than a drive to cover it up.”

* “Second, the letter does not directly forbid bishops from reporting abusers to police and prosecutors. Instead, it communicates the judgment of one Vatican office that mandatory reporting policies raise concerns. It’s not a policy directive, in other words, but an expression of opinion.”

* “Third, the Congregation for the Clergy at the time was under the direction of Colombian Cardinal Darío Castrillón Hoyos, whose reservations about bishops reporting their priests to civil authorities have been already well documented.” Some other Vatican officials at the time, including Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, disagreed with Castrillon Hoyos’ approach. Pope John Paul II put Cardinal Ratzinger in charge of the Vatican’s response to the sexual abuse crisis in 2001.

Vatican spokesperson, Jesuit Fr. Federico Lombardi, said the letter “correctly insists on the importance that canonical legislation be respected, precisely so that guilty parties not have a basis to appeal.” The “moral and canonical concerns” mentioned in the letter, Lombardi said, concern the sacrament of confession.

 

 
comments powered by Disqus
 
about this blog 

Search this blog

 Subscribe to Just B16 newsletter
get posts by email or
rss Subscribe to Just B16 RSS feed

  Useful links about the crisis

Question: Who said: ‘Not all sex involving children is unwanted and abusive’?
Peter Hitchens | Daily Mail, London | 13 Sept 2010
Answer: The Pope's biggest British critic

The Pope deserves better from Britain
London Telegraph
Pope Benedict XVI is a serious man whose message risks being drowned out by misguided noise

It’s those who oppose Pope Benedict XVI’s visit who are the real bigots
Daily Mail
'I have been trying to puzzle out the sheer bloody mindedness and unreasonableness of some of the Pope’s critics', writes and Anglican journalist.

Report to the Council of Europe
Cesnur | June 22
Statement of Dr Massimo Introvigne

Do You Despair Over the Current Crisis in the Church?
New Oxford Review
Anyone with a sense of history should know that such things can go on and have gone on throughout the life of the Church.

Time takes aim at the papacy, and misfires
Our Sunday Visitor
But then, who thought Time would want to separate itself from the media pack?

Eunuchs for the Kingdom of Heaven. The Argument over Celibacy
Chiesa
A handy summary of the history of clerical celibacy.

Pope Benedict XVI and the Sexual Abuse Crisis
Our Sunday Visitor
Introduction to a just published book from Our Sunday Visitor president Gregory Erlandson.

more...

 Recent Posts
My Brother the Pope
11 May 2012
Pope Benedict goes where no pontiff has gone before…
30 Jun 2011
No “smoking gun” in Irish TV revelations
21 Jan 2011
Pope and clerical abuse: evidence for the defence
6 Dec 2010
US “surprised” at election of Benedict - Wikileaks
1 Dec 2010

 MercatorNet blogs
Population issues: Demography is Destiny
Family social policy: Family Edge
US political scene: Sheila Liaugminas
News about bioethics: BioEdge
From the editors: Conniptions

 Archive
May 2012 | Jun 2011 | Jan 2011 | more >>

  From MercatorNet's home page

The desperate dream of the Islamic Caliphate
21 Jul 2014
Most Muslims look upon the proclamation of a caliphate as preposterous.

Reflections on an unforgiving day
18 Jul 2014
What links the twin tragedies of a downed plane over the Ukraine and Israel's invasion of Gaza?

Five steps Malaysia Airlines must take after its second disaster in four months
18 Jul 2014
Inaction could sink the company.

Why we all deserve free, yummy dark chocolate
18 Jul 2014
If Obamacare offers free contraceptives, why not free chocolate? It has health benefits, too.

Mothers in shackles
16 Jul 2014
It’s not only in Sudanese prisons that women give birth chained.


 Tags
abuse, abuse crisis, Andrew Sullivan, AP, apologies, arrest the Pope, atheists, Austria, Belgium, Benedict XVI, Bishop Pierre Pican, Bishop Walter Mixa, Bishop William Lori, bishops, book reviews, Boston Archdiocese, Boy Scouts, Brendan O'Neill, campaign, Canada, canon law, Cardinal Angelo Sodano, Cardinal Castrillon Hoyos, Cardinal Hans Groer, Cardinal Newman, Cardinal Ratzinger, Cardinal Sean O'Malley, cartoons, Castrillon, Catholic Church, celibacy, charles scicluna, Charter for the Protection of Children and Young People, chastity, child pornography, Church, clean-up, clerical dispensations, Communism, condoms, Connecticut, conspiracy, cover-ups, credibility, Damian Thompson, David Cameron, defrocking, Der Spiegel, Dershowitz, documents, Evangelical, Evo Morales, Fr Alvin Campbell, Fr Lawrence Murphy, Fr Marcial Maciel, Fr Rene Bissey, Fr Stephen Kiesle, France, George Pell, George Weigel, Germany, history, history of crisis, holiness, Holy See v. John Doe, homosexuality, humor, imported priests, insurance, international law, internet, Ireland, Italy, Jeff Anderson, Jeffrey Anderson, Jewish defender, Jewish defender Sam Miller, Jewish defenders, Jewish sex abuse, Jews, John Jay report, judicial activism, Kathryn Jean Lopez, Kentucky class action suit, Kenya, Kiesle, Laurie Goodstein, law, Lawrence C. Murphy, lawsuit, lawsuits, Legionaries of Christ, Levada, Light of the World, Lithuania, London Times, Malta, media, media bias, media coverage, media credibility, media criticism, media ethics, Michael Gerson, Milwaukee, Miranda Devine, Monsignor Charles Scicluna, Monsignor Georg Ratzinger, moral authority, moral panic, morale, narratives, Natinal Review Online, Nazi, new atheists, New York, New York times, New York Times, Obama administration , ordination of women, Oregon suit, origins, paedophilia, Papal credibility, Papal visit to UK, pedophilia, Peggy Noonan, penance, Peter Tatchell, Pew Forum, Pius XI, Polanski, policy, Pope Benedict, Pope Benedict XVI, Pope John Paul II, pornography, Portugal, priest abuse crisis, priest crisis, priests, propaganda, public approval ratings, public opinion, public relations, punitive damages, Reformation Day, reforms, Rembert Weakland, reporting abuse, resignations, Richard Dawkins, Ross Douthat, Sacramentorum Sanctitatis Tutela, same-sex marriage, Schönborn, Scouts, secrecy, secularism, seminaries, sex abuse, sex abuse safeguards, sex abuse survivors, sexual abuse, sexual revolution, sin, Sinead O’Connor, SNAP, sociology, sovereign state, Spain, Spiked, statistics, statute of limitations, stem cells, Stephen Kiesle, support, supporters, Tarciso Bertone, teachers, theologians, theology, transparency, Twitter, U.S. bishops' charter, U.S. priest abuse scandal, UK, UK visit, United Kingdom, US, US politics, US schools, Vatican, Vatican media response, victims, victims of sex abuse, video, visit to UK, Washington Post, Weakland, Wikileaks, youth, YouTube,
Follow MercatorNet
Facebook
Twitter
Newsletters
Sections and Blogs
Harambee
PopCorn
Conjugality
Careful!
Family Edge
Sheila Reports
Reading Matters
Demography Is Destiny
Conniptions (the editorial)
Information
our ideals
our People
Mercator who?
partner sites
audited accounts
donate
New Media Foundation
Suite 12A, Level 2
5 George Street
North Strathfield NSW 2137
Australia

editor@mercatornet.com
+61 2 8005 8605
skype: mercatornet
© New Media Foundation | powered by Encyclomedia | designed by Elleston