Latest posts  
July
13
  2:22:28 AM

What they’re really saying in that Senate hearing room

This is some novel reporting, and better than a lot of other Senate/Court coverage out there right now.

In the polite but white-hot world of confirmation hearings, senators and witnesses don’t always say what they want to say. So they speak in code.

Here’s a translation of what was said in Sonia Sotomayor’s confirmation hearing, and what the players actually meant:

___

WHAT SHE SAID: “If I introduced everybody that’s family-like,” Sotomayor said with a strong voice and a smile, “we’d be here all morning.”

WHAT SHE MEANT: I may not look like all of you but, trust me, I’m no different from every other family-loving American. I’m surrounded by people who love me.

___

WHAT HE SAID: “Judge Sotomayor’s journey to this hearing room,” said Judiciary Committee Chairman Patrick Leahy, D-Vt., “is a truly American story.”

WHAT HE MEANT: If you love America, you’ll love Sotomayor — or at least vote for her.

___

WHAT HE SAID: “The confirmation of Justice Louis Brandeis, the first Jewish-American to be nominated to the high court, was a struggle ripe with anti-Semitism,” Leahy said. “Likewise, the first Catholic nominee had to overcome the argument that, as a Catholic, he’d be dominated by the pope.”

WHAT HE MEANT: Criticize Sotomayor at your own risk. You don’t want to sound racist.

___

WHAT HE SAID: “Let no one demean this extraordinary woman,” Leahy said.

WHAT HE MEANT: Criticize Sotomayor at your own risk. You don’t want to sound sexist.

Good stuff. Creative thinking in that room packed with media and politicians.

WHAT HE SAID: “I expect this hearing and resulting debate will be characterized by a respectful tone, a discussion of serious issues, a thoughtful dialogue and maybe some disagreements,” said Sen. Jeff Sessions, the committee’s senior Republican.

WHAT HE MEANT: This is a lifetime appointment, folks. We’re not going to roll over and play dead.

___

WHAT HE SAID: “Politics has no place in the courtroom,” Sessions said.

WHAT HE MEANT: Democratic politics has no place in the courtroom.

Read it all, and use it as a translation key for this week’s events.



 
about this blog | Bookmark and Share

Search this blog

 Subscribe to Sheila's newsletter
rss Subscribe to Sheila's RSS feed

 Recent Posts
Dozens of Catholic institutions sue Obama
22 May 2012
Seeing the human face in mass media
15 May 2012
Motherhood
13 May 2012
First Lady fashion
11 May 2012
Obama’s unsurprising marriage epiphany
10 May 2012

 MercatorNet blogs
Population issues: Demography is Destiny
Family social policy: Family Edge
Style and culture: Tiger Print
News about bioethics: BioEdge
From the editors: Conniptions

 Archive
May 2012 | Apr 2012 | Mar 2012 | more >>

  From MercatorNet's home page

Sensing the sacred
25 May 2012
Is there a sense of the sacred that even the non-religious can share?

Could geoengineering save the planet?
25 May 2012
And who is thinking about the ethics of a technological quick fix?

A thought experiment about marriage
24 May 2012
A world in which sexual intimacy could not produce children would never have come up with the idea of marriage.

Australia’s lifeline: its precarious sea lanes
23 May 2012
Large, isolated and rich, Australia needs to cultivate a friendship with the US to survive in an dangerous world.

It’s only natural
22 May 2012
The bitterest debates today in the public square often turn on what is "natural". The Chinese sages had a lot…


 Tags
faith, Obamacare, Declaration of Independence, health care rationing, ACLU, Manhattan Declaration, Alliance Defense Fund, Planned Parenthood funding, Taxes, Archbishop Timothy Dolan, partisan politics,