- Free newsletter
- The Latest
- Topics
-
About
Ignore the woke critics of Hungary: Budapest is a vibrant, bustling place
You can see immediately why bestselling author and conservative blogger Rod Dreher likes his adopted city of Budapest: it’s right there on the beer bottles!
I arrived in Budapest in the late afternoon as I usually arrive in cities – that is, hot and tired and in a cranky mood from non-existent airline food. The 100E bus from the airport, like most airline transports, takes you along the least scenic route to the city centre.
Then again, it only costs US$3 instead of $40 for a taxi. In Budapest’s case, however, public transport means driving past mile upon mile of dilapidated Commie tenements now falling into even more disrepair, covered with pseudo-Gantsa graffiti.
By the time the bus let me off near the apartment I rented, at Kálvin Square near the Hungarian National Museum, I was almost falling over from the heat. It’s early September and the temperatures are in the mid-90s Fahrenheit. I can’t help but think: Good God, what have I done? I could be visiting Zurich where it’s cool and there’s a lake!
I stumbled the few blocks to my apartment building, entered the main door digital keycode I had received, and dropped off my bags. I then went in search of a cold beer and something to eat.
And that’s when I saw it: right there on the beer bottle I ordered was Rod’s name in bright white letters: “Dreher.” It’s the Coors of Hungary, one of the most popular of Hungarian beers (brewed since 1854!).
I, too, might be warmly disposed to a country that named its national beer after me – even though I do have a nice island in Florida and a Kansas town named in my honour.
The magical city on the Danube
Rod Dreher, of course, is perhaps the most famous of Budapest boosters… but there are many others. I’ve been regaled by family and friends for years about what a magical place this venerable city on the Danube actually is.
Famous for its stunning architecture and beautiful women, Budapest has been a symbol of Central European elegance and sophistication for as long as I can remember. My daughter visited during a Model United Nations field trip her senior year in high school and announced that I just “had” to visit Budapest (although, truth be told, she liked Vienna even better).
The real reason people talk about Budapest, however, is due to Hungary’s determination to preserve its capital city’s best qualities from all the cultural “enrichment” EU leaders seem determined to inflict on the rest of Europe – mass migration of young men from the Middle East and Africa, an epidemic of violent crime, drug addiction, entire villages of homeless living on the streets, and a general sense of cultural decline and desperation.
Budapest, it is said, has been spared much of this.
It is a city where young women in tight mini-dresses walk safely late at night, strolling from ruin bar to ruin bar in the Jewish Quarter, and not worry about being raped by gangs of Muslim men.
Very few young Hungarians appear to sport tattoos, and those that do limit themselves to a few discreet “tramp stamps.”
The stench of cannabis is virtually non-existent, and while I do occasionally see people sleeping on park benches, the streets and parks are free of tents and other signs of permanent homeless encampments.
Because I’m staying for only ten days, I’m walking all over the city and am using the tram lines regularly. As is my custom, I’m also staying in an inexpensive apartment in a “working class” district near the Danube, and there is nowhere I feel uneasy walking late at night.
This is in dramatic contrast to, say, America’s capital city of Washington DC, with one of the highest murder rates in the world, where on a recent visit I had to avoid three-quarters of the city after dark if I didn’t want to get mugged.
A modern city lacking in diversity
Much of this is due to Budapest’s lack of diversity and resistance to multiculturalism. This gives Budapest a definite “old world” vibe – that, and the stunning neo-Gothic architecture.
When I was younger, say 40 years ago, when you visited a European city you expected to meet, well, Europeans, and you did. When I visited Paris when I was 19, virtually everyone I met spoke French and was French. That was the reason you visited France!
The same was true of my youthful visits to Munich, Copenhagen, Rome, Malaga, and so on. When I visited Munich, I interacted exclusively with Germans, ate German food, tried to speak German, learned about German culture, and so on.
Today, throughout western Europe, that is often not the case.
Many European cities, like many cities in North America, enjoy the cultural enrichment of diversity.
They resemble the polyglot Los Angeles of the Ridley Scott dystopian film Blade Runner, a multicultural food court in which thousands of Koreans, Nigerians, Chinese, Ethiopians, Somalis, Russians, Italians, Mexicans, Bangladeshis, Indians, and Filipinos all crowd together speaking hundreds of different languages and with whom few have anything in common with their neighbours.
This United Nations phantasmagoria can be fun for a day or two, but on a daily basis – as a place to live – it’s exhausting. Anyone who has moved to London recently knows this. When half the women on your street wear bourkas, it’s difficult for a Westerner to feel at home.
This is not Budapest.
Budapest, for all its faults, is Hungarian through and through.
It’s a large, bustling, crowded, energetic, very modern European city full of Hungarians. (Unlike London, where the population is now only about 36 percent native British.)
The mystery of the Hungarian people
I know all this because I can’t understand a single word anyone is saying. Not one. This means they’re speaking Hungarian, perhaps the most incomprehensible language on earth to non-native speakers. More about that in a moment.
The only foreigners you run into are tourists (Israelis in the Jewish quarter, Chinese tourists taking pictures) and Thai women asking if you want a massage. The ratio of tourists to residents seems incredibly low. I am regularly approached by people on the street, asking for directions in Hungarian, so that means people assume that those they meet are likely residents, not tourists.
As for the Hungarians themselves, they look for all the world like a group of fit midwestern Americans or Bavarian Germans at a picnic in the park: in fact, it’s eerie how much they resemble ordinary Americans or Germans. They’re a good-looking bunch, the young men tan and flexing their biceps, the women flashing cleavage. They’d be at home at any mall in Los Angeles or Frankfurt.
Except for one thing: it appears the Hungarians are actually from another planet.
They speak a language that is utterly unlike any language on earth (except for Finnish) and totally distinct from the languages of all their neighbours.
The best historians can determine, the world’s 15 million Hungarians are the descendants of nomadic tribes originally from one side or the other of the Ural Mountains in Siberia, in the far north of what is now Russia. Sometime in the first millennium, these ancient tribesmen, who called themselves the Magyars, left their homelands and gradually headed south towards central Europe and the Carpathian basin.
They spoke an early version of Hungarian known as Proto-Uralic – a non-Indo-European language. One group of these people broke off and headed north, eventually settling in what we now call Finland. But their languages developed independently so that Finnish and Hungarian today, although sharing many similarities, are no longer mutually intelligible. (To my untutored ear, however, Hungarian has many of the same tonal qualities I hear in the Finnish detective TV series I compulsively watch at home.)
In other words, this unique tribe of nomads spoke a language unlike any of the other peoples then in the area – not the Latin of the Romans, or the Celtic languages of the Celts, or the early German of the Germans, or the Basque language of the Basques. It’s utterly unique.
By the early Middle Ages, the Magyar tribes were raiding settlements across central Europe. However, around 800 AD, these raiding peoples cast their eyes on the lush meadows of the Carpathian Basin, a vast lowland tucked between the Carpathian Mountains to the north and the Alps to the west. A pagan prince settled his people in the area, driving out other groups, and, as legend has it, the pope agreed that they could settle in and take possession of the Carpathian Basin if they agreed to convert to Christianity – and that is precisely what they did.
An ancient Catholic country
The warlord known as King St Stephen I, born to baptized Christian parents, committed his people to the Christian religion and was crowned the first king of Hungary on Christmas Day in the year 1000 AD, with a crown perhaps sent to him by Pope Sylvester II. They still have the crown, the oldest royal crown in continuous use.
The basilica in the centre of Budapest, St Stephen’s Basilica, was built in the king’s honour and contains a macabre relic of the man himself – his mummified but still recognizable right hand – triumphantly and creepily on display in the glass case at a side altar.
Thus, Hungary was a kingdom that lasted for roughly 900 years, despite invasions by the Ottoman Turks and rule by the Austria-Hungarian Empire (with the emperor taking on the title of King of Hungary).
All this came to a screeching halt with the “brother wars” of World War I and World War II.
After World War I, the victorious allies divvied up roughly 40 percent of Hungarian territory to various real and invented states (Hungary’s neighbours). That’s why Hungary today is “surrounded by Hungarians” in Serbia, the Czech Republic, Slovakia and so on.
This is also why Hungary reluctantly sided with the Axis Powers in World War II.
The catastrophe of Europe’s civil wars
Hitler promised Hungary’s leaders that they could regain the lands taken from them after World War I and that he would help Hungary resist Soviet communism. At the time, Hungary had one of the largest Jewish populations of Europe, roughly ten percent of the population.
To appease Hitler, Hungary’s leaders adopted harsh anti-Jewish employment measures but refused to deport or harm Hungarian Jews. As the Holocaust memorial organization Yad Vashem puts it, “most of the Jews of Hungary lived in relative safety for much of the war.”
However, by the end of the war, the Hungarian government was secretly making peace overtures to the Allies and the Nazis responded by invading Hungary in March 1944.
This is why the catastrophe that befell Hungary’s large Jewish population happened all at once in one brief period beginning in May 1944, when 434,000 Hungarian Jews were deported to Nazi death camps, primarily Auschwitz, and gassed.
In October, 1944, just months before the end of the war, Hitler removed Hungarian Regent Miklós Horthy from power, installed a pro-Nazi puppet as prime minister, and proceeded to wipe out the remaining Jewish population of Budapest.
Nearly 80,000 Jews were lined up on the banks of the Danube River, told to remove their shoes, and shot at point-blank range, their bodies simply thrown into the river. That is why there are now 60 pairs of iron shoes lining the banks of the Danube near the Hungarian parliament, a memorial to those who lost their lives.
It was one of the great tragedies of World War II, the last-minute mass murder of Hungarian Jews, organized by the notorious Adolf Eichmann, right at the end of World War II.
It is also why the Soviet Union had the excuse to “liberate” Hungary from the Germans and then impose its flat-earth Communist ideology for the next 45 years – despite the Hungarians rebelling outright in a heroic but doomed uprising in 1956.
What all this means is that the Hungarians are a very ancient people who have lived in the same basic area in Central Europe -- preserving their linguistic and cultural identity despite multiple conquests – for at least a thousand years and probably longer.
Join Mercator today for free and get our latest news and analysis
Buck internet censorship and get the news you may not get anywhere else, delivered right to your inbox. It's free and your info is safe with us, we will never share or sell your personal data.
Preserving Hungary for Hungarians
They may look and dress like they should be in a Calvin Klein ad, their Apple earbuds firmly in place, but Hungarians have a fierce sense of national identity borne, at least in part, by their linguistic isolation. At least 93 percent of the people who live in Hungary today are ethnically Hungarian.
All this goes to explain why Hungarians don’t really want the “enrichment” and diversity of mass migration that EU leaders inexplicably demand. They’ve seen the riots, stabbings and rapes being perpetrated in other European cities– by groups of migrants angry that they’re not being given more benefits – and frankly want nothing to do with it.
As with most polls of European citizens, polls of Hungarians show that the overwhelming majority support the strong immigration laws promoted by the Hungarian Fidesz Party and Prime Minister Victor Orbán, a man regularly denounced by EU bureaucrats as a “strong man” for his refusal to accept the quotas of impoverished migrants the EU demands of Hungary.
As in America, polls in Europe are highly politicized and used primarily for propaganda purposes, their results dependent upon the data sample and the way questions are phrased. Nevertheless, poll after poll has shown that roughly 70 percent of Europeans believe that their countries take in too many migrants, according to a recent survey carried out by BVA Xsight.
In other words, Hungary is doing what most Europeans actually want, preserving their country as a homeland for their own people.
Because of the rapid rise of anti-immigration, populist parties in France, Germany, Denmark, Sweden, Italy and the Netherlands, EU bureaucrats recently created a reform of immigration policy dubbed the New Pact on Migration and Asylum, approved by 27 nations of the EU despite opposition from Hungary and Poland.
As with similar proposed legislation in the US, the new rules allow for greater vetting and detention of illegal migrants and “asylum seekers” but still allow for massive numbers to be allowed in. The EU pushed this reform to quash the rise of populist parties but, apparently, to no avail: recently, Germany’s anti-immigration Alternative for Deutschland (AfD) party received the greatest percent of the vote in its history.
Visit Budapest to see what a city can be
In the end, Budapest is a bracing example of what European nations are losing: it’s the proud capital of a proud people, one determined to maintain its nation, culture and history.
One final initial observation: everywhere you go in Budapest, you see construction going on with massive scaffolding and cranes in place.
They are rebuilding everything, healing decades of government neglect and the deliberate destruction of their historical monuments – a reality that ordinary Americans have seen in their own history recently. For example, the Communists destroyed many monuments of Hungarian history and royal buildings in the Buda Castle, tried to destroy St Stephen Basilica (the centre of Catholicism) and succeeded in placing the Marxist Red Star atop the Hungarian Parliament.
Yet today, old royal buildings are being completely rebuilt according to extant architectural plans. Entire neighbourhoods are being refurbished. There is an energy and optimism here – as well as vast amounts of money being spent – that are lacking in many decaying American inner cities.
Budapest shows you that large cities don’t have to be ugly and dangerous. In fact, they can be magnetic places people want to live in, bustling urban centres that are safe at night and full of energy and excitement.
And in the end, that’s the reason to visit Budapest: to discover what cities can be.
They don’t have to be urban ghettoes from which families flee to the suburbs for safety. They can be just the opposite. They can attract young families eager for the culture and energy and excitement they provide. Visit Budapest to experience what cities can be, if only our leaders would listen.
Hungary’s policies are often criticised in the West. Are you as optimistic about Hungary as the author?
Robert J. Hutchinson is the author of numerous books of popular history, including Searching for Jesus: New Discoveries in the Quest for Jesus of Nazareth (Thomas Nelson), The Dawn of Christianity (Thomas Nelson), The Politically Incorrect Guide to the Bible (Regnery) and When in Rome: A Journal of Life in Vatican City (Doubleday). Email him at: [email protected]
This article has been republished from the author's Substack blog, Disputed Questions.
Image credit: Bigstock
Have your say!
Join Mercator and post your comments.
-
mrscracker commented 2024-09-22 08:41:45 +1000It’s true that Britain and the States have different varieties of English but I find that we, like other former colonies, retain more of the older vocabulary. That works in a similar way for Cajun French. They use some words that died out on the continent many years ago.
Hundreds of thousands of expat US citizens live in Mexico and not a few seem to resist learning Spanish. Especially those living in English speaking communities. So it’s just a part of human nature I think to avoid learning a 2nd language unless you have no choice. -
Christopher Szabo commented 2024-09-22 00:05:19 +1000I am aware of that, mrscracker (but many Brits would argue that that isn’t English at all! :) )
I will point to what I noticed while in the U.S. already in the 80’s, namely that many Spanish speakers preferred not to speak English and demanded Spanish-speaking interpreters for courts, police and officialdom generally. (I spent most of my time in the South-west and the South. (Virginia, N. Carolina etc.)
I foresee that as a possible problem.
Thanks for the kind words. -
mrscracker commented 2024-09-21 22:20:44 +1000Immigrants learn English in the
States also Mr. Szabo. If not in the first generation, then definitely in the 2nd. I’m not a big fan of our public school system but it does ensure fluency in English.
Where I live older people still speak French, especially older people of colour. Schools today are attempting to bring fluency in French back to our children.
English, Spanish, French, and native tribal languages are all a part of US culture and history.
But we’re not Hungary. Hungary is entitled to its own rules, language, and culture. And the right to preserve those.
God bless! -
Christopher Szabo commented 2024-09-21 19:48:02 +1000Steven Meyer,
Hungarians, as you might have read, are from outside Europe. Also, these are legal immigrants. Hungary insists that people who come learn Hungarian, not an easy language. As long as they assimilate, they are welcome to contribute. Nothing controversial there.
What is controversial is the US/EU are demanding that European countries be overrun and turned into Third World disaster areas. You can see the Irish, the Dutch, the Danes are all rebelling against this and Hungary simply saw the danger earlier due to our prior experiences with the joys of Islam. -
Steven Meyer commented 2024-09-21 14:47:46 +1000David Page
Strongly agree. With one quibble.
What if the native population make it hard, if not impossible, to become assimilated? -
David Page commented 2024-09-21 09:36:07 +1000Multiculturalism is nonsense. I have long believed that those we allow into the US should be willing to be culturally and politically assimilated. Those who are unwilling should be deported. The problems arise with those who would use the argument I just made as a cover for racism.
-
Steven Meyer commented 2024-09-21 09:16:03 +1000Christopher Szabo and mrscracker
In other words the Hungarian Government is bowing to the inevitable and allowing in immigrants from outside Europe
Which is a good thing. -
Christopher Szabo commented 2024-09-20 20:42:26 +1000Steven Meyer, Hungary has over 400,000 immigrants at this time. There is a sizeable Chinese presence, as well as other people from Asia, including Tibetans. Then there are those educated in Hungary from the Middle East or Africa who have chosen to stay or returned. There are also Western pensioners who want to live in a normal country, and there are Jews from the West who have fled the new pogroms. There are also many Ukrainians who want to stay.
As these people integrate into the mainstream of Hungary, while keeping those bits of their traditions that they wish to, they will also add to our numbers. See the Pechenegs, Cumans, Mongols, Jews, Swabians, Saxons, Vlach-Romanians, Serbs, Slovaks, Rusins, Gypsies…. you get the picture.
I notice the critiques of Hungary all mention our supposed xenophobia, but fail to talk of the real issue, which is high crime, terrorism, murder, grooming gangs and the slow but certain destruction of Europe’s great cities.
I am sorry to disappoint you, but we ain’t disappearing anytime soon. -
David Page commented 2024-09-20 18:19:58 +1000Ah, those “woke” fools who still believe in democracy. I’m sure Berlin was vibrant and exciting in the ’30s.
-
mrscracker commented 2024-09-20 13:29:12 +1000Hungary seems only a fraction of a percentage point behind Australia and the United States fertility rates. So if Hungary’s heading for extinction, so are we.
But I think we’ll all still be here in the next century. And probably still quarreling.
🙄 -
Steven Meyer commented 2024-09-20 11:55:10 +1000mrscracker Hungary is going to find it hard to preserve its unique culture without Hungarians – which is the way it’s headed
-
Christopher Szabo commented 2024-09-20 00:58:43 +1000I think Mrs Cracker’s point is well taken and reasonable. One reason for all the shouting (and not just about Hungary) is they refuse to accept the straightjacket the US, EU are trying to force on them.
-
mrscracker commented 2024-09-20 00:40:21 +1000I think folks in places like Australia & North America think the rest of the world is similar to theirs. Not every nation is made up of widely diverse immigration over the past 400 years. It’s perfectly fine for a small country like Hungary to preserve their unique culture. And it’s ok for us to be happy with ours. At least what’s left of it.
-
Christopher Szabo commented 2024-09-19 18:12:46 +1000I tell you what. You keep your culture, we’ll keep ours.
-
Paul Bunyan commented 2024-09-19 17:58:05 +1000No one has to abandon their culture. But traditions aren’t always worth preserving. Slavery used to be commonplace and acceptable (at least for everyone who wasn’t a slave).
The Aztecs practiced human sacrifice, and parents often saw their children as property, only good for labor on the farm, around the house or to take care of younger children while their parents were at work.
I don’t think any of those things should persist into the future.
I also don’t think motivating parents with income tax exemptions will make them better parents. If anything, it’ll cause them to view their children as cash cows, used to better their financial situations. -
Christopher Szabo commented 2024-09-19 17:40:45 +1000Bunyan again: So let me ask you. Native Americans, Khoina, Black British, Australian Aborigines must forget their culture, language and customs. To do anything else is a ’racist dog whistle."
I wonder who is the racist here? -
Christopher Szabo commented 2024-09-19 17:37:59 +1000I can just see you drooling over the death of a people. Yeah, soon they’ll all be dead and we can grab their land. But we might surprise you, as we have done so often in the past.
-
Christopher Szabo commented 2024-09-19 17:36:24 +1000Really? So I can’t be what I am? I must go be what someone else tells me to be. Forget it, Comrade.
-
Paul Bunyan commented 2024-09-19 16:29:51 +1000Being concerned about a nation’s “cultural identity” is nothing more than a racist dog-whistle.
There’s nothing fair or good about favoring one group over another. Orban’s speeches have very problematic agendas and policy goals. -
Steven Meyer commented 2024-09-19 09:17:10 +1000As I pointed out in my previous post, all this talk of national sovereignty, etc, is moot.
The Hungarians are vanishing. Soon, pfft, no more Hungarians.
Take a look at that population pyramid
https://www.cia.gov/the-world-factbook/static/d44426252b18eadc7497d02cd9884cbc/15d60/HU_popgraph2023.jpg
In a nation of just 10 million. Biggest cohort is in the 45-49 bracket. -
Christopher Szabo commented 2024-09-19 05:07:17 +1000Ms Bagshaw. I understand your point. I grew up in three countries, speak a lot of languages and am most interested in many cultures. However, what you might not be aware of is that Hungary is not, by any stretch of the imagination, only one culture. Hungarians are made up of peoples descended from Turkic nomads, like the Cumans, Iranian Sarmatians, Hunnic Szekely and the Magyars. Plus after about half the Hungarian population was wiped out by the Islamic Turks, the Hapsburg rulers who were unfortunately elected by parliament brought in Slovaks, Romanians, ethnic Germans (like my mother’s family) Serbs and many other peoples. Just because people appear to be “white”, a meaningless term, does not mean there is only one culture.
Also, because of our long history of being killed in huge numbers (I believe only the Jews have suffered more) we wish to choose who comes to what is left of our country.
I hope that is somewhat clearer now. -
Bridget Bagshaw commented 2024-09-19 03:50:23 +1000Mr. Szabo:
Actually, I would do all I could to protect my country’s sovereign rights.
But allow me to elaborate. As a child of immigrant parents and living in one of the most cosmopolitan and safe cities, I couldn’t imagine growing up without all the diverse cultures, languages and faiths that have enriched my life. In my humble opinion, Hungary is missing out. -
mrscracker commented 2024-09-19 02:58:08 +1000I have four daughters and eight granddaughters. Their safety at night is a pretty important concern to me.
-
Christopher Szabo commented 2024-09-19 02:01:40 +1000What are you accusing Hungarians of, Bridget B? Why not come out and say it. I know you don’t like the idea of national sovereignty, but we have battled for it for five hundred years. Before that we had it for 600.
Join the queue of Hungarophobes! -
Bridget Bagshaw commented 2024-09-19 01:12:44 +1000Surely you jest.
Your criteria for determining a city’s best qualities are that it is safe for scantily clad women to bar hop late at night, the stench of cannabis is low, and no one has any tattoos. For real?
Also, what’s that word we use when people are unable or refuse to recognize the rights, needs, dignity, or value of people of particular races or geographical origins. I can’t help but think this article is overflowing with it. -
Christopher Szabo commented 2024-09-18 18:23:52 +1000Emberson Feddersen: You just don’t have a clue, do you? Calling for millions of migrants who have a memory of having ruled one of the most oppressed people in Europe’s history will mean the end of our people. No doubt you couldn’t care less.
We do.
So yes, by pushing your lies of ‘2025’ (whatever that is) and repeating Left-wing propaganda, which does aim to injure our people, you are indeed asking for just that, the death of a people. Genocide, in other words.
See the gleeful post by Meyer below, where he falsely claims our corruption is equal to that of Cuba. HAH!
I know all about corruption, having lived in Africa. One indicated — as in Cuba — of corruption is that nothing works. In Hungary, everything works well, efficient, normal. So much for that. Have a look at the World Bank’s map on the subject, and then please stop repeating lies:
https://tinyurl.com/k2wj7t6n -
Steven Meyer commented 2024-09-18 10:39:17 +1000After a brief boost from an influx of Ukrainians fleeing their country ahead of the Russian invasion, the population of Hungary has resumed its accelerating decline.
Fertility is well below replacement despite Orban’s best efforts. In fact, it was higher in the last years of Communist rule than it is now.
Budapest may well be a bustling city but the countryside is depopulating.
It has slipped steadily down the corruption perceptions index since Orban came to power. In fact it’s now on a par with Cuba!
Thus was it ever. Nations, cultures, empires rise and fall. Nothing is forever.
My best guess. Hungary as we know it today will no longer exist before the end of this century.
So it goes. -
Emberson Fedders commented 2024-09-18 10:02:15 +1000Hello Christopher Szabo. Just re-read my original post looking for where I must have accidentally called for the genocide of Hungarian people. Couldn’t find it.
What we have here, Christopher, is a classic strawman argument. Used when one doesn’t actually have a rebuttal to an argument.
Nice try. -
Christopher Szabo commented 2024-09-18 01:37:02 +1000I agree. I haven’t been to Vienna for a long time, but would love to go again. I’ll be in Istanbul soon, but for too short a time.
-
mrscracker commented 2024-09-18 01:12:47 +1000Budapest is an amazing place for sure. Budapest, Istanbul, & Vienna were my favorite cities to visit in Europe. Well, Istanbul’s partly in Asia.