- Free newsletter
- The Latest
- Topics
-
About
Your children are more important than your dreams
The phenomenon known as Ballerina Farm on Instagram is one of the most popular moms in America. With her eight children, a gaggle of hogs, endless Instagram videos of baking from scratch, and her 10 million followers, Hannah Neeleman is a mom to be reckoned with. Oh, and she also wins beauty pageants like a boss. And is a Julliard-trained ballerina.
A recent article on Hannah and her husband, Daniel, threw the digital world into hysterics. A main source of outrage is that Hannah gave up her dreams of being a ballerina to be a wife and a mother. Many are also horrified that Hannah has little time to herself and sometimes works to the point of exhaustion.
Newsflash: All mothers of young children have little time to themselves and work to the point of exhaustion frequently.
Giving up dreams
But let’s get back to the ballerina thing. When Hannah put on her first pair of ballerina slippers, did her parents think, “Hallelujah! No motherhood for her! No wifehood for her! We want our daughter to remain a single, solitary soul dancing into old age wearing tutus and toe shoes forever!” Not likely.
Here’s the thing. Hannah is not alone in “giving up her dreams” to raise a family. Almost everyone does this. And it is not a shame, a tragedy, or a sign of oppression. It’s called growing up. And women are not the only ones who regularly “give up their dreams” for the sake of their families. Most men give up their boyhood dreams of becoming professional athletes to do something far less glamorous.
My dad is such a man. He was a great football player in high school. In fact, some might say he was phenomenal. The local newspapers ran stories about him, football was his life, and he seemed destined for greatness.
Then he met my mom. They got married and soon there was a baby on the way. My dad was practicing with the college football team of his dreams at the time. My dad realised there wasn’t time in the day for him to go to school, go to work, and go to practice, and nurture his marriage. So, he gave up football.
He gave up football.
He poured himself into work and school and caring for my mother, who was throwing up multiple times a day. He eventually graduated from college. My mother eventually had the baby and then had three more. One of them was me.
My parents both worked like crazy keeping our family afloat, and it floated. Barely. I had an absolutely stellar childhood full of camping trips and backyard swings and never enough money. But that last part isn’t what mattered the most. What mattered the most is that I knew my parents loved me. I knew they’d make any sacrifice for me.
My parents when they were dating, 1966
Sacred sacrifice
Parenthood is a position of sacrifice. Author and psychoanalyst Erica Komisar says parenthood comes with “the sacred obligation of nurturing.” To nurture others requires sacrifices of self. This does not mean we fail to care for ourselves or that we never pursue hobbies or do anything for fun ever again, but it does mean we offer humongous amounts of time, energy, resources, sleep, and emotional investment in the name of our children’s wellbeing.
All decent parents do this. All decent parents make sacrifices so that their children can eat, sleep in a bed, and possibly even take dance lessons or join a basketball club. Only a tiny sliver of the population will dance or play ball professionally, and even that won’t last forever. But family relationships will last — if we’re wise enough to forge them. And somehow, amid all the sacrifice, we end up the better for it.
Join Mercator today for free and get our latest news and analysis
Buck internet censorship and get the news you may not get anywhere else, delivered right to your inbox. It's free and your info is safe with us, we will never share or sell your personal data.
If no one moved on from their dreams of throwing footballs or tying on their toe shoes in order to bear, raise, nurture, and support children, the world would be full of old people with bad knees, concussed heads, and empty homes. And the world would collapse in one generation because no one would have kids. There would be a whole lot of lonely has-beens out there without their own little cheering squad (these are known as families) to remember they used to be something — and to see that they still ARE something.
Pink tights and varicose veins
So, should Hannah Neeleman have rejected the marriage proposal so she could “follow her dreams?” Well, if she had, she would have had the great pleasure of pulling her pale pink ballet tights on over her varicose veins when she turned 60, without an adoring audience to laud her fading grace and beauty.
But instead, she had kids. And she’s having the time of her life raising them. And when she’s 60, she’ll be surrounded by people who exist because she exists, and those people will laugh and cry and dream and dance with her.
Hannah and her family
My dad “gave up” football, but did he? He passed his love of the game on to my brothers. He spent countless hours playing catch with them and watching their games and playing football with them and the neighbourhood boys on frosty Thanksgiving mornings. His new dream was to watch them — and me — excel not just at football, or chess, or soccer — but to excel at life. His new passion became us and my mom. That is not a tragedy. It is a triumph.
My Dad and his family
A wrecked life?
At a recent family gathering that included one of his infant great-grandsons, my dad was reflecting on walking away from football. He said,
“I’m happy I did it. It was the right choice. I know what it’s like to score a winning touchdown, but laughing with babies is better.”
If you had told the 18-year-old version of my dad that someday he’d think babies were more interesting than football, he would have laughed his head off. But the truth is, as life pushes on, we don’t just abandon our dreams; our dreams change. They mature, they grow, and they become better than we could have imagined.
Did giving up professional ballet wreck Hannah Neeleman’s life? Did giving up football wreck my dad’s life?
You decide.
What do you think of Hannah's choice to be a mother instead of a professional ballerina? Leave your thoughts below.
Kimberly Ells is the author of The Invincible Family. Follow her at Invincible Family Substack.
Image credit: Pexels
Have your say!
Join Mercator and post your comments.
-
Tim Lee commented 2024-08-25 06:47:55 +1000You’re welcome, Mrs Cracker! I have seen first-hand how women blossom inro motherhood despite their initial misgivings. We need to hear more from women like yourself and Kimberly Ells, who asks: “When have influencers, pastors, professors, celebrities, or even their own moms told young women that their anatomy is innately valuable, amazing in its complexity, and unparalleled in its importance? When have we told them that their own future children might need them more than Silicon Valley needs them? When have we told young women that it is good to grow up to be a mom?”
https://www.mercatornet.com/should-young-women-surrender-their-fertility
… and Lea Singh who writes: “Am I loving it? I am loving them, though staying home is no picnic in the park. Every day it involves a lot of spit, sweat and tears. Is this why I have a law degree?… The bottom line is that I have been on the corporate ladder, and I have also worked for great nonprofits – and while in the working world I was always replaceable, I am not replaceable to my children.”
https://www.mercatornet.com/seriously_is_this_mommy_business_really_worth_it -
mrscracker commented 2024-08-24 22:14:48 +1000Thank you so much Mr. Lee. I agree completely.
-
Tim Lee commented 2024-08-24 15:15:20 +1000Steven and David, this article and others like it celebrate the joys of motherhood. It taps into women’s natural instinct to bring forth and nurture life – a counter-cultural story that needs to be told. Of course, some women find their calling in a career but many others are caught up in pursuit of a dream that leaves them childless and unfulfilled in a primal sense. We give too much weight to “gainful” employment at the expense of being needed in a fundamental way and the joy of meeting that need.
-
mrscracker commented 2024-08-20 04:24:06 +1000I didn’t know that about Ursula von der Leyen. Thank you for sharing that info. Mrs. Angela.
-
Angela Shanahan commented 2024-08-19 14:51:14 +1000I think from my point of view this is a bit simplistic. I do note the would be ballerina has her own blog etc..,so she is utilising her mothering of so many kids for lucre. Good luck to her.
I am a mother of nine kids . . Having all the kids has given me a good insight into life and where politics hit the fan, BUT, it holds you back professionally., and that is frankly frustrating. I note that the spruikers for super fertility always talk about people like the ballerina lady as role models. They don’t talk about Ursula von derLeyen, who has seven kids, is a qualified medical doctor and is the president of the EU! -
David Page commented 2024-08-19 12:35:40 +1000The question isn’t whether raising children is fulfilling. Of course it is. But is it the only path to fulfillment? Is it the only way to serve? I wouldn’t have thought so.
-
Steven Meyer commented 2024-08-19 11:56:46 +1000Florence Nightingale
-
Marty Hayden commented 2024-08-19 01:30:32 +1000Perhaps the greatest irony of the human condition is that we are never happy thinking only, or even primarily, about ourselves. To be truly happy we need to become other-directed. The happiest people you know are usually busy helping other people. That’s the irony: to be happy we have to work to make other people happy. And that, my friends, is called maturity. That is what marriage and family does to a person. It’s helps them grow up and mature quickly. So in short, yes, they were happier, much happier, giving of themselves to their children. In my humble opinion.
-
Steven Meyer commented 2024-08-18 11:53:24 +1000David Page,
I’m still trying to understand the point of this piece.
BTW turns out that Daniel Neeleman is the son of David Neeleman who fathered 10 children.
See his Wikipedia Page:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Neeleman
The one thing that interests me: How many kids David’s other children have? Do we see the beginnings of a regression to the norm? How many great grand children will David have? -
David Page commented 2024-08-18 10:18:24 +1000We all give up (or alter) our dreams when we face the realities of adulthood. It goes with the territory. But there is more than one path to fulfillment. I once posted a picture of me holding one of my infants and titled it, “The meaning of life”. Another picture I posted showed a mother and child walking on the beach. The child asks his mother “What is the meaning of life?”. The mother answers “You are.”. A school teacher friend of mine, childless, asked me if I thought her life was meaningless given my posts? Of course not, I replied. What you do is just as important. Does the author think that child bearing is the only important act one can do? bIt was for me, but that was my calling. I was born to raise children. I never wanted to do anything else. But that is not true for everyone.
-
Steven Meyer commented 2024-08-17 17:09:20 +1000“Did giving up professional ballet wreck Hannah Neeleman’s life? Did giving up football wreck my dad’s life?”
How can I possibly say?
How can anyone say?
On the face of it the Neeleman’s made life choices that worked for them. Great. Sounds like lives well lived.
Other people make different choices that may, or may not, work for them.
So what point is Kimberley Ells trying to make? -
Angela Shanahan commented 2024-08-17 15:09:00 +1000And by the way, we don’t all have varicose veins at 60, even after nine kids !
-
Juan Llor Baños commented 2024-08-17 07:31:59 +1000Magnífico artículo!!
-
mrscracker commented 2024-08-17 00:38:36 +1000The world of professional ballerinas is not so great. As lovely as ballet is to view, a dancer’s life behind the scenes can sometimes be dysfunctional & unhealthy. I would not encourage my daughter to enter into that world professionally.
-